Friday, 19 October 2012

  • It's My Page, So Why Do I Feel Restricted?



    I apologize ahead of time. This is going to be long because I need some place to vent.

    Facebook is supposed to be my page, right? Well, my profile, anyways. I have the mouth of a sailor, but because I have family on my FB, I try not to curse. I might slip and write something mild, but I try to avoid the F word at all costs (unless I'm on Ange's wall ). But now I feel like I have to censor myself further. I am VERY pro-breastfeeding, and encourage it at every opportunity. I am VERY into car seat safety. As for circumcision? I'll leave that for an entire paragraph on it's own. I do CIO, but a different version. I believe in bedsharing. I like to wear my baby when I can. I cloth diaper. I have a specific way I do things, and I feel like I can't share anything like that on MY OWN FACEBOOK PAGE!! So, instead, I'll share it here.

    Recently, a very good friend informed me that she was offended by my breastfeeding posts and links and whatnot. Maybe offended isn't the word. We talked it out, she let me know her feelings in a respectable way. She didn't tell me I was wrong, she supported me. But she was bothered by it. And it wasn't just me. It was other people on her friends list. But she and I are still good friends. But other people? Complain complain complain. Why?? It's my page. Don't like it? Unfriend me! Or hide my posts. I don't care. Better yet, come and talk to me. Not in an accusatory way. But let me know your feelings. Perhaps ask me to change my settings so you don't have to see those posts. I am an adult. I can handle it, I promise. I must also add that even though I am very pro-breastfeeding, I am NOT anti-formula. All 3 of my kids had formula. I even stocked up before G was born, anticipating a breastfeeding fail like with S and AJ. She had formula 1 to 3 times a day, depending on if I had to work, or if she was going through a growth spurt. So, I am not against it. Entirely. I'm just amazed that people find it "just as good" as breast milk. Fact is, it isn't. Formula doesn't change to adapt to your baby's changing needs. But regardless, it's there for moms/babies who need it. And again, I'm okay with it. S and AJ were exclusively formula fed around 3ish months. And they're alive, and healthy.

    As for car seat safety, it's one of my biggest issues. I can't tell you how many parents use theirs incorrectly. Car seats do NOT belong on the seat of a shopping cart. This is in the manual of EVERY car seat. Either put the baby in the basket of the cart, wear your baby, or use the stroller. It really isn't that hard to do. Did I ever put my kids on the top? Yes, before I knew better. But I took the time to look into everything more carefully as I became more experienced as a mother. I learned the way the straps should be in the seat (at or below shoulders for rear facing, at or above for forward). I believe in extended rear facing. G is 13 months and still in her infant seat, rear facing. She will be rear facing for a longggg time. Well, until she is at least 3. I believe in using the correct seats until they're mature enough to sit without one. That means that my 5 year old is still in a 5 point harness. We have tried a booster with him. He won't sit back, and he doesn't stay still. The harness seat is what I need to keep him safe. My 9 year old is still in a booster. Also, the chest clip on every seat is just that- a CHEST clip. Not a belly, or a neck, clip. Chest. Should be at armpit level. Check it, and check it every time you buckle your child in. Coats do not belong in the car seat. Use a blanket. 

    CIO- I don't like the idea of my child screaming and crying, thinking that I've just up and left them. G was a year when I even considered starting. She was old enough to understand that, just because she couldn't see me, it didn't mean that I was gone for good. And I went back in often to lay her back down, rub her back, or nurse her again. We still do it. We start the night out in her bed, and she finishes in my bed. We are okay with this. It works for us. We even bought a king size bed so that there would be room for all 3 of us. Not to mention, AJ likes to join us at about 4 (by then, his meds wear off, and he needs the security of us). I still use my pillows, G has her own, and we use blankets. I don't sleep with a knife in the bed like the commercials want you to think. It's not dangerous. I don't drink or do drugs. I don't take sleeping meds. G is old enough to roll over and move freely if something were obstructing her. I've woken up to a slap to the face, or a pinch on the arm, because I had my arm over her, or I was laying on her legs. 

    As for baby wearing and cloth diapering, it is just something new to me, and something I enjoy. The diapers are cute, I don't have to worry about running out of diapers at 4 AM because of my baby having diarrhea and going through them all. I don't have to worry about increasing costs because of the plant in Japan blowing up. And I don't have to worry about her outgrowing a size before we use them all. I buy cute, one size cloth diapers. They will fit her until she's potty trained. Not to mention, once we're done with them, I can sell them for 75% of what I paid. It might be a hefty cost upfront, but by the time we're done using them and we resell them, we're looking at paying MAYBE $100 total for diapering. I think we see the real reason why I cloth diaper. Because I'm cheap lol We also use cloth wipes, and I make my own wipe solution. Talk about saving tons of money!

    Okay, now the topic that seems to be a hot button for nearly everyone. Circumcision. I stand on the fence on this one. AJ is circ'd. If G had been a boy, he would have likely been circ'd as well. Why? Because that's just what is normal to me. My infant did not experience any pain or discomfort during the process. How do I know? I was there. He slept through the whole thing. No, he did not pass out from shock. He was asleep when I carried him to the room, and he stayed asleep while I laid him down. He stayed asleep while his diaper was removed, while lidocaine was applied, and so on. When I say I made sure he was numb, I meant it. My baby felt nothing. When he woke, I nursed him. Those videos you see on YouTube are sickening. I 100% believe these are the worst of the worst. Maybe some doctors don't use lidocaine. Mine did. This is something that you simply cannot change my mind on. If I happen to have any more kids, and if they are boys, they WILL be circ'd.

    What about vaccinations? This is another hot button. If I mention this on my wall, oh man. Forget it. My children are FULLY vaccinated. The only one who has been on a delayed schedule is G. She has a weakened immune system. She is ill often. We try to plan a doctor visit for when she's not so ill so that we can do one of two shots. Some don't hold in her body, others do. So, because of that, we rely on others to be fully vaccinated to keep her healthy. If my baby were to ever get deathly ill from a preventable disease because someone didn't vaccinate, I'm going to go off. I do not put other children at risk, don't put mine. And if you chose to not vaccinate still, please let me know ahead of time. I need to do what's best for my daughter. 

    I'm just sick and tired of being ridiculed about my choices. I'm sorry if what I do offends you. I'm sorry that you aren't confident enough in your choices that you feel the need to attack mine. If you're offended with what I post, that is YOUR problem. Not mine. I am not forcing you to look. I am not making you read them. I'm simply doing my part to better educate others. There were PLENTY of mistakes I've made in my years of parenting. I've let car seat straps get too loose. I've put thick coats and snowsuits on my kids in their seats. I put AJ and S forward facing as soon as they hit 1. I've put their car seats on top of the cart. I used disposable diapers and wipes. I still do occasionally. I've put my kids to sleep on their bellies. On their backs. Their sides. Even on the couch. We all make mistakes. The point is, you can learn from others. Those of us who do post often about car seats and vaccines and circumcisions, we only do so because we care. I can appreciate others opinions, even if they differ from my own. What I cannot appreciate is someone telling me I'm wrong for trying to educate people. I never claimed I was an expert. I never said I was better than anyone. I never said that my mothering abilities are superior. I'll admit that there are a ton of people that I personally think should never have kids. Unfortunately, there's nothing I can do about that. All I can do is take the time to post what I know and care about, and maybe those people will actually start to become better parents. Do you think Octomom looks at my wall?

    From here on out, I'm going to post what I want. Screw you if you don't like it. Hit the unfriend button. I don't care. The only thing I ask is if it somehow offends you, or it bothers you THAT much, please come to me and tell me. Maybe you have a personal hang up about a specific topic. I can add a list on FB and put you in it, and hide those kinds of posts from you. It's really not that hard.


    Have you ever felt like you had to censor yourself on FB or other social websites?


    image source

Comments (27)

  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    If you have opinions and share them on a public forum, don't be surprised when others share theirs.

    "If G had been a boy, he would have likely been circ'd as well. Why? Because that's just what is normal to me."

    And in some societies, your daughter would be circumcised. Why? Because that's just what is normal to them.

    What is considered a social norm doesn't automatically make it morally acceptable.

  • Italianmama32103@xanga

    @QuantumStorm@xanga - If we were in another culture and G was circ'd, then that would be what was normal in that culture. I've done my fair share of research. I looked at the pros and cons of every aspect of my parenting decisions.


  • sarahsmurfette@xanga

    @Italianmama32103@xanga - I've never spoken with someone who was there when the circumcision was done (my son is also circ'd). Were you nervous/scared about it, in the moment? I would have been. Fear is irrational, no matter how much research you've done.

  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    @Italianmama32103@xanga - "If we were in another culture and G was circ'd, then that would be what was normal in that culture."

    Yes, but does that make it morally permissible? Because if it is, you are effectively arguing that genital mutilation, such as done with boys in the Western countries and with women in other societies, is acceptable.

  • gwacemom

    Well, at least no one was offended by the "screw you" part of the blog. 

  • Italianmama32103@xanga

    @sarahsmurfette@xanga - In all honesty, no. I was not. The only thing I was nervous about was me passing out! He did fantastic, he healed wonderfully, we were happy. No cries, no problems urinating, no problems with breastfeeding due to it, nothing. 


    @QuantumStorm@xanga - In some cultures, a female circumcision is just knicking the hood of the clitoris and just drawing a pindrop of blood. As for removing the whole hood, there is no anesthesia, and the girls are older. Their legs are bound after the circumcision. That's different, IMO, from a male circumcision. Again, if that were my culture and that's what knew as normal, then that's how it would be.
  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    @Italianmama32103@xanga - If the practice is socially accepted, then by your argument of "social norm = acceptable", the type of procedure wouldn't matter... right?

  • Italianmama32103@xanga

    @QuantumStorm@xanga - I never said that. Please don't go putting words in my mouth. I said that

    in my opinion

    , they were different.

  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    @Italianmama32103@xanga - You are arguing for the legitimacy of genital mutilation (circumcision) by citing social norms for it. If that is the primary determinant in the acceptability of such an act, then you have to concede that other forms of genital mutilation are acceptable as well. If you cite different procedures, then the issue is no longer a matter of social norms alone but the type of procedure as well... which would then undermine your social norms argument and beg the question, "WHY genitally mutilate your child in the first place?"

  • Italianmama32103@xanga

    @QuantumStorm@xanga - When my child becomes your child, then I will worry about your opinion when it comes to what I did with my son. Until then, parent your children the way you want to. I will continue to parent mine the way I do. In case you forgot what the last sentence was in that paragraph, I'll copy and paste it here:


    This is something that you simply cannot change my mind on. If I happen to have any more kids, and if they are boys, they WILL be circ'd.
    Have a fantastic night 
  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    @Italianmama32103@xanga - Having two divergent opinions on a subject does not mean they are equal in validity. Believe it or not, stupid opinions DO exist.

    You choose to rationalize the genital mutilation of your children by citing social norms, I choose NOT to do so. Have a good Friday!

  • gwacemom

    Hmm...and I'm the one being told to keep it mature. Yes, that makes sense. 

  • Italianmama32103@xanga
  • Italianmama32103@xanga

    @gwacemom - You are never mature. What do you expect? I love you!!!

  • gwacemom

    @Italianmama32103@xanga - Love you too pookie and at least I am amusing.

  • Erika_Steele@xanga

    I wouldn't worry about it.  You are entitled to your own opinion and so are others.  They don't have to agree with you.

  • Mandi

    When we got pregnant with our second, I had some drama with a (by marriage) family member because she was dealing with infertility (as was I, I just didn't complain on Facebook every day as she did). I eventually removed her from my friend's list because it wasn't worth trying to censor myself (sharing pregnancy news, etc) to try and please one person out of 300. 


    I love the diversity of my friend's list and am so thankful that there is the ability to hide posts from the feed!
  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    FB is a public forum. You put out your opinion, others put out theirs. If you want to be true to yourself, you will simply have to expect some to disagree and then not let it bother you. If you don't want to hear naysayers, don't put it out in the public eye for people to comment on.
    I usually censor what I say on FB because it's not a diary and I can be true to myself outside of the forum. I don't depend on it to exclusively represent me.

  • sarahsmurfette@xanga

    @Kuai_le1010@xanga - That is an excellent point, FB is not a diary.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @sarahsmurfette@xanga - TMI and FB could almost be synonyms. Funny thing is, FB is set up as a marketing tool for businesses so that people will openly reveal volumes of information about themselves at no cost. Every time an app is used or a Like button for a business, movies, stores, etc is pressed, we are being used as marketing tools. Just learned that in my e-commerce class.

  • LadyGwenivere@xanga

    I agree with everything except what you said about vaccines and circumcision...
    But especially agree with the fact that its your page, and you should be able to say whatever you want to. I have stopped caring what other people think about me and my FB. A couple of my cousins have a problem with the fact that Im a foster/adoptive mom, and I told them if they didn't want to see what I posted, they didn't have to read it. Both unfriended me, and i really dont care.

  • Xx_DeUce_xX@xanga

    I didn't read through your entire post, but circumcision is fine if that's what you want for your kids. I honestly believe it's a personal choice but the practice is quite strange in the majority of the world. After all, it is a part of your penis. I am sure your children will be bright enough to figure out how to clean their foreskin if you left it on.

    I do, however, totally agree with you about the FB thing. You can post whatever you want. If they don't like your shit they can take you off their feed. As for me, I try not to offend unless someone has offended... so I just make some of my posts private viewable only by my close friends, who, as my friends, shouldn't be offended by anything I have to say!

  • rachmorgan01

    I truly feel some things shouldn't be shared on FB. It's a public forum, not a diary. For example, I could have gone the rest of my life not knowing about my friend's toddler's explosive diarrhea.... I don't think people should be filling their posts with vulgarity or other obviously offensive things, but I'm not the kind of person to go around mothering everyone on my friend's list. Most of the time, I just keep scrolling down the newsfeed. If someone is constantly posting things that I find offensive, I remove their posts from my newsfeed. We don't have to like what other people post just as others don't have to like what we post. This being said, I think if you're going to get personal in your status updates and whatnot, you should be able to take the criticism. The phrase: "Don't dish it out if you can't take it" comes to mind whenever I'm on FB. People share so much on their FB wall, and then they get all pissed off when someone has a different opinion. Most comments can be chalked up to difference of opinion, and those are the comments you really shouldn't worry about. You have your way of doing things, they have their ways, and as long as you have healthy, happy kids at the end of the day, who cares what someone else thinks? Now, if people are full on bashing you and insulting you, it might be time to re-evaluate who you allow to see your posts and/or who you allow to be a part of your life....

    As far as all the parenting choices are concerned, what works for me may not work for someon else, and who am I to judge? All kids are different, and therefore, all parents must be different.  

  • FreeSpirit97@xanga

    Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I am not a parent yet, but I agree with all of your decisions. I don't have a facebook anymore, but from what I remember, people do post too many private things on there. Like someone mentioned above me, it's not a diary. But what can we do? lol. 

  • WaitingToShrug@xanga

    I am honestly a little surprised that you are surprised that these are controversial topics that people will sound off on. A couple of things you can do- customize the post so that those people won't see it. Delete those people. Or don't bring up things like circumcision and vaccinations and breast feeding. 


  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

Who recommended?