Monday, 13 August 2012

  • Just Say YES!



    Maybe I'm a slow learner and most moms have learned this already but it's a revelation for me...

    My relationship between my kids and I has progressively become more of a fight as they've headed into their 3's and 4's. It was getting to the point that I almost couldn't stand to hear the sounds of their voices, which is so tragic. Right after one of the kids' huge blowups occurred, I was seriously considering running away and hitch-hiking my way to a Costa Rican beach (the danger didn't even bother me as much as my kid's meltdown). I started cleaning up and coincidentally found some of the tips-for-parenting papers that the pediatrician always hands out during check-ups. I decided to peruse them before throwing them out.

    On them was the standard stuff like feed your kids healthy foods every day, brush their teeth, etc but there was also a single line that read, "Say yes as much as possible". It instantly reminded me of the Oscar Mayer Turkey commercial where the mom constantly says no. The commercial annoys that crap out of me but I know firsthand that as a mom, I say no A LOT and it's fatiguing to have to say it all the time. It's a natural tendency for kids to want to push the limits and do what they want - so saying yes often is hard to do. I knew that whatever I'd been doing wasn't working anymore and that I should take the advice instead of thinking, they don't know my kid. I know, what kind of crazy person would ever take a doctor's advice?

    As my kids have grown, my parenting has had to adapt from  giving constant care to dealing with bad attitudes. It seems like every month to even every couple of weeks there are new things to learn, a little personality shift and intellectual/emotional/physical growth. I was thinking about all that after I read the a fore mentioned advice and how there probably needs to be a shift in my parenting again; an update of sorts - Mommy4.0. The kids no longer need a super-involved mommy who is at their side all the time nor do they need someone who says no constantly even when they do a lot of naughty things. I decided to stop saying no so much and be more of a yes person, even when they were doing something wrong. I knew it was going to take a lot of creative thinking and would take much more thought and patience than simply giving an easy yes answer to everything, unlike Jim Carrey in Yes Man.

    I am all for having well-disciplined children who are obedient and listen well but it seemed like the more my children acted out and the stricter I got, the worse they became...kind of like negative quicksand. Consistency is important in discipline and children absolutely need discipline for their own well-being but I knew I was doing something wrong in other areas of parenting because of my kid's attitudes. They were combative even when I was nice. They have manners and say please and thank-you but they can get upset and angry so quickly over nothing! I had already backed off a good deal and they've subsequently learned the art of playing by themselves creatively over the past month but the stubbornness/rudeness/temper flares have increased. Up until my son was about 3, I could sweetly ask him to put something back and he would. Now that he's wanting to do things his way more, it doesn't work. My daughter has always been contentious but it has gotten much worse through her 3's and 4's.

    So my effort to change attitudes in our home had to absolutely start with myself. Like Dr. Phil says, "You can't change the people around you, only your reaction to them". I can't change them, they need to be who they are, so I had to change my reaction. My first step: figuring out how to have more yes even though I'm saying no. It's an art of thinking a lot before speaking, I've realized. For instance, my son wanted to take 2 nail files out of my drawer while I was trying to do my make-up. My initial response would be, "No. Mommy doesn't want you to touch that."
    Instead I asked, "Is that Mommy's?"
    His response, "Yes."
    Me: "Do you like mommy's files?"
    Him: "Yes"
    Me: "That's great, I like them too but I bet you know that you shouldn't play in mommy's drawer with mommy's things, right?".
    Him: "...right..."
    Me: I bet we can find something more fun to do! Do you want to put on daddy's sneakers?"
    Him: "Yes!!"

    I've found that the best way to get compliance is to ask questions that are answered with yes's-es. I'm not really saying yes as much as my kids are and I've definitely reduced my no's. We went to the pet store which is normally a huge pain but again, I kept saying things that were positive and could be responded to with a yes and the trip was so easy. We went to Target, which is a huge hassle normally, yet it turned out to be fun. We even went through the toy section and somehow avoided complaining and screaming for toys. It was so much easier!
    It was the same thing with getting dressed. I let the kids pick out their clothes and when my daughter became dead set against wearing what she had picked out, instead of telling her no, I simply said, "I like the jeans that you picked out. The flowers on them are pretty...do you think they're pretty?" She said, "Yes! They're pretty." Then I said, "...and you did a good job of picking out that neat Cinderella shirt. It looks nice on you." Next thing I know, she heads over to her jeans and t-shirt and puts them on. No fight, no struggle, no headache. It's been an amazing day where we have enjoyed being around each other. No buttons being pushed or intense fighting. In fact, they squabbled at each other for a short minute and then stopped of their own accord. Amazing!

    I did have to mention a time-out just once but that was it. Just once. Which brings me to the second thing I'm doing to keep discipline from being a no-nofest. I give them two choices: shape up or get disciplined. If they are being ugly I ask, "Would you rather behave and have a good time or do you want to go in time out?" 9 out of 10 times, they say they'll behave and they do. I use the Supernanny technique of time outs and it works pretty well, especially when they are given the choice to adhere or go in time out.

    It's going to take a lot of practice for me to continue going down the less-no-path but it's the doctor's order and I want to say, it's a good one. Maybe the approach is working because it's new and the kids aren't used to it but maybe that's just what they need at his age.  I'm sure it won't work for ever because as they grow, they need different approaches. I guess that's one of the hardest things about being a parent. Figuring out how to change with them.


    How can you practice saying "yes" more?

    image source                                                               

Comments (25)

  • SHEERROSE@xanga

    I think if/when I become a mom someday it will be hard. If this happened to me I would feel very disconnected to my children and I don't feel like I could communicate with them.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @SHEERROSE@xanga - Most kids go through some rough stages. If you've heard of the terrible two's, then you have somewhat of a heads up. However, I've observed between other children and my own that the 2's are not all at bad but the 3's get pretty seedy. I think my specific experience is especially difficult because my kids are only 10.5 months apart and the three of us spend a lot of time together. 

  • LondonsMommy

    I'm glad that is working for you! I hear all the time that we need to treat our children with respect. Yelling "No" at them makes them feel crappy and angry. It's wonderful to let them make decisions, or at least think they are making them with your encouragement. My daughter has been throwing huge tantrums, but she is only 12 months old. I'll have to wait a couple years to put your advice into action! lol 

  • leahKtutu@xanga

    great post!  I sometimes don't realize when I don't do this, but I definitly realize when I do. 

  • ulvenNixie@xanga

    Oh I love this! Instead of yelling at your kids all the time to do this or that (or not to do this or that), you're letting them connect to the situation. I think they would learn more from experiences like the ones you described than Mommy yelling at them all the time. I'm going to keep this in mind for if I ever have children. It sounds a lot more interesting and productive in the child's growth than the Ever-Present No.

  • chronic_masticator@xanga

    I'm so glad I found this!  I've been having the same struggle with my four year old.  I'm exhausted after spending my whole day telling him no, but I really never thought about how tiring it is to constantly hear it.  I'll have to try this when he wakes up tomorrow.  Thank you!

  • dw817@xanga

     I think I would make good NO parent.

    "Can I go outside, Daddy ?"

    NO

    "Why can't I ?"

    NO

    No, meaning I can't go outside or no because you don't know why ?

    NO

    Oh, so you do know, but you won't tell me ?

    NO

    Oh, so you don't know at all why ?

    NO

    Meaning, you're not in the know ?

    NO

    No, meaning you are in the know or 'know' you want me to discover and know life for myself ?

    ...

    (This could go on for a-while, great fun for an inquisitive and incredibly patient kid)

  • Pollypinks@xanga

    You are having wonderful success, and I say there are multiple ways of dealing with little critters.  Every mom knows her kids better than anyone else, so whatever works, go for it.  My thoughts ran along the lines of deciding with the kids in advance what I'd do if they acted up again in a certain way.  Perhaps a time out, perhaps removing a favorite toy, and, if the behavior continued numerous times, the favorite toy went to the Salvation Army, with me reminding them that we'd talked about it, and they knew what was coming next time around.  They all have currency.  My daughter didn't have much currency except her books and favorite blanket.  One day I was so mad I took her blanket and put it in the trash, only to retrieve it because one, I'd made it, and two, I felt horrible, because she was my shining child who really never did anything wrong.  We all have to tread these waters, but one thing is for sure.  They can't grow up with parents who count to 3 and do nothing.

  • where_are_my_fritos@xanga

    I, personally, love this approach, and I am super excited that it's working for you at the moment.  Kids like to feel involved and important.  By giving them choices, you give them something to be involved with and something to focus on.  It's quite lovely.  

    @Pollypinks@xanga - I can't stand when parents count to three, but there are no consequences.  It turns into a game instead of discipline.  

    On an unrelated note, I also hate when parents say no and *immediately* spank their kids before giving them a second to assess the command and react.  They could have calmly stopped, but the parent didn't wait to find out. 
    It's just all around better when children are treated as people and individuals with respect as opposed to things to be directed and buttoned all the time.  
    People (adults & kids) don't like to be told what to do with every waking minute of their day and others (leaders) don't like to feel like they have to control someone's life every waking minute.  It gets stressful for both parties...unless, you're just into that sort of thing, but that's another post altogether!
  • LadyGwenivere@xanga

    FINALLY a good post on this site!
    This approach is fantastic, but you have to retrain your brain to think this way. BUT when you do it, and it works, the change in your home will be pretty outstanding.
    I don't like saying "no" all the time. Kids don't need to hear that 24/7, and I get sick of saying it.

    @Pollypinks@xanga - the counting to 3 thing lasted less then a week in our house.. Our toddler would immediately chime in with "2.. 3.." well she can count to 10 now!

  • mommalosingit@xanga

    I have literally been working on this lately. And what a change! 

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @LadyGwenivere@xanga - You are so right about having to retrain your brain! I slip back into my old ways sometimes (like first thing in the morning when I can't think) and end up regretting it. I'm glad kids are resilient because it is a work in progress.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga
  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @mommalosingit@xanga - I'm so glad!
    I really like this approach because it feels wonderful to guide my children instead of fighting with them.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @where_are_my_fritos@xanga - Thank you, it turns us from fighting to feeling like family.
    Counting to three only works if there's always a guaranteed punishment at 3.0000001 seconds.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @ulvenNixie@xanga - Thank you! It makes such a huge difference in the atmosphere of our house. 

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @leahKtutu@xanga - It can make such a huge difference.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @LondonsMommy - lol, yeah, she is a bit young. At least you can get a plan of action ready for when she becomes a toddler with her own agenda.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @Pollypinks@xanga - I agree that discipline is important. That why I like this approach, they're not getting in trouble as much for little things and since discipline and no's have been reduced, they're much more effective when handed out. Kids start to tune out when they hear the same thing over and over again.
    And you're right, every child is different.

  • rachmorgan01

    I am glad to see I'm not the only one who uses the "yes" approach with my children when it seems that saying "no" is the more common way to parent. I have 3 very stubborn, strong willed kids, so telling them they can't do something/have something usually results in WW 3 breaking out. We have found offering them an alternative keeps them from freaking out, and also gives them the satisfaction of knowing they can make a decision. There is still discipline in our home because it's not like we ever ignore their bad behavior or let them get away with doing anything we all know they can't do, but we've noticed disciplining them is more effective when they aren't constantly being told "no."

  • caroliiineee@xanga

    Something my sister does with her kids, is she gives them two choices to choose from so they feel like they have some control, for example, "do you want to get dressed in your room or in the bathroom?" instead of just telling them to get dressed. Or, "do you want to go inside now, or in three minutes?" 

    It works really well for her.
  • sarahsmurfette@xanga

    @caroliiineee@xanga - That is also my tactic. Although I do reserve the right to say no. Rejection an "no" is a part of life, too. There is no escaping it.

  • Kuai_le1010@xanga

    @sarahsmurfette@xanga - It's not that I don't say no, it's just not a constantly heard word in my house anymore. When No is used all the time, kids tune it out.

  • AnneMunchmeyer@xanga

    I don't have kids and get along well with my nieces and nephew but I don't know how it would be to be a parent. Maybe I will say yes to some thing easily...

  • tribaldia8@xanga

    Thanks for sharing.  Parenting hones the skills of becoming the better man.  I like what you write.

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

  • Post a Comment

  • Say it with Minis! (?)

  • Profile Pic

    Default | Choose » (?)

About the Author

Who recommended?