Thursday, 19 April 2012
-
Did Your Parents Yell? Do You Yell?

When I was a kid, I always had a really hard time making friends. I was ugly, weird and changed schools when I was eight after my parents broke up. Two years after moving I finally made friends and was so excited to bring them over to my house after school and have sleep overs. But they all stopped coming over fairly quick.
So, I'd keep inviting them over and they'd either decline or suggest we do something else. Finally after asking why they never wanted to come over, they admitted that they felt awkward coming over just to hear my parents scream and they didn't like it when people yelled.
My mom and her boyfriend fought, and they fought a lot. Over stupid things mostly, but they would scream, holler, swear, and just go on for the entire day a few times a week. It became predictable after a few years. They'd fight about something, say they're broken up and over and never going to speak to each other again. Anytime we went on a trip I always knew the trip would be canceled, them broken up, and back together a few times before we finally left. I never really paid much attention to it, though. Everyone fights, right? They always made up and stayed together, so I was never really too concerned about it. The only time I really cared is when they'd yell at me for something me or my friends did when they were there, but otherwise I blocked it all out.
And from then on until graduation from high school, my friends rarely came over to my house. I never really minded because after they told me, I was too embarrassed of my family and scared they'd get in a big fight to invite anyone over, anyways.
So here's the question, did/do your parents yell? As a parent, do you yell? I understand that it's not the best form of communication, but is it always a bad thing? Can yelling be okay sometimes?
Post a Comment
- Back to momaroo's Momaroo Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in momaroo's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend



Comments (40)
My mother didn't yell, that was my dad's job. He was too busy traveling for it to be effective though. My neighbor's mom yelled all the time. She was fucking nuts, a piece of work. When she finally yelled at me (five years old) I stopped going over there. Who yells at a five year old? Like spitting, screaming, big eyes yelling. It was terrifying.
My son only responds to yelling. You don't even have to yell, just use a stern voice. He laughs if he is spanked. he'll even take you hand and smack his butt with it. he doesn't care if you take things away. He'll find something else to do. You can not let him touch any of his toys; he will just run laps around the house. You can send him to the naughty chair and he will just pout while he is in it and go back to doing what he was doing once you let him go. If you yell, he'll stop and remember what you yelled at him about.
our son (adopted) was basically screamed at for the first six months of his life, and off and on until he was 18 months old. His birthmom would scream at him for not sleeping, not eating, and then she'd wake him up when he was sleeping so he'd cry and she'd recognize him as the same baby.
Our soon-to-be-adopted babygirl was screamed at by her birthfather for the first 4 months of her life, and she was shaken by him twice that we know of. He still yells at the access sessions and it effects her for the rest of the day.
so no, I don't yell. I raise my voice to get attention (and it stops them right in their tracks).. but I find if I am really needing to get a point across, I pull my little one in close, get down on their level, and talk softly so they have to be quiet to hear me. Its very effective. And my son knows that if momma gets really quiet she is really mad.
Yes my parents yell. It seems silly. You can say the same thing with a level voice, yelling doesn't add anything of value to the logic of the conversation nor does it make the other person listen more attentively.
When arguing, yelling is the recourse of the unintelligent and moronic.
I don't want to start anything since I am obviously a stranger and I don't know much about you. But I wonder if what you are describing more indicates an emotionally abusive household. The things that make me sad are that the yelling was basically non-stop, you seem to indicate you were somewhat ignored, and you say right away that you were ugly. Your Mom and her boyfriend yelled in front of your friends, they couldn't even control themselves in the public eye. They caused you public humiliation and didn't care (or they wouldn't have done it, or once done, realized and never done it again). Of course no parent is perfect, but what is described here is not "normal" yelling. Not in my opinion. And I'm sorry you had to evolve and learn how to avoid this in order to have friends. And that's another worrying thing, they weren't worried you didn't have a friend for two whole years after you moved. They weren't concerned you were alienated.
To the question. Do I, as a parent, yell? My kids are 5 and 2. Yes sometimes I yell. Sometimes I must. But it is nothing like what is described here. I yell when someone is about to get hurt and I can't physically get there in time to stop it. I yell when I have to try and stop a fight and nothing else is catching their attention. Sometimes I do yell out of sheer frustration, but that is rare and is the thing I work on stopping.
I agree with @LadyGwenivere@xanga - close, soft talking on their level does usually get the point across more deeply. It is a bit more frightening though, so I'm not really sold on which is better - but I think there are appropriate times for both forms of communication. Just like everything else in life, in moderation.
I think it can be a question of temper. I always feel like the people in the south of europe yell a lot more than the people in the north for example. It's funny. I guess can be a cultural thing. I also live in an area in my country where people seem to be typically loud. But they are always loud, they even yell when they are being nice. Noise (such as loud voices) doesn'T annoy me when I feel like it isn't dangerous. I don't think it has to be bad.
I think if you make the expierence that yelling is followed by things like physical agression or neglect or someone yells at you when you already cry or does it to someone else, it is scary.If someoe is simply loud but soon friendly again and if it's their general nature it's no big deal. I had a teacher who always looked as if her head was going to burst whe she got angry, and at first I found it scary but later it wasn't anymore. Another point would be wether it's predictable. If someone suddenly freaks out about something they normally tolerate you see something is wrong. (possibly that's what your friends felt, because they weren'tused to it).
It depends on the person what is scary.
P.S.: I am very quite but I think people who force themselves to be kind but obviously are angry are more creepy. I so agree with the picture.
My Dad yelled, sometimes...when things were very serious. Mom never did. They would rarely have yelling match fights, as my Mom would normally just give him the silent treatment. I was yelled at a few times, and I stopped the behavior...it was intimidating and frightening.
I'm a mom to two boys, 6 and 4. I agree with Sarah, sometimes it's necessary. When you ask politely more than a few times, your voice slowly starts raising enough to where the attention is on you and they can focus on what you're saying. Attention spans are so short. There have been times where the yell is a, "Mom's ran out of patience and has lost her shit," but normally it's just to control a situation.
Adults yelling at each other is not normal. I was not raised in a home where my parents yelled at each other and they got along horribly. They just didn't yell. They discussed without us around or whatever. They would sometimes yell at us if say we ran into the street without looking.
I do yell sometimes at my kids, like when the cat brought a lizard into the house and I freaked out yelling at the kids to get it out. haha Well, that might have been more terrified screaming. I have yelled at them when their actions can cause harm, as I was as a kid.
There's a difference between yelling, "STOP" and yelling, "You stupid idiot stop doing that shit right you little monster".
@sarahsmurfette@xanga - I yell at my kids when I'm in the shower and I can hear them fighting! lol Well, they don't fight but argue but still I hate that and I'm not getting out of the shower to fix the issue, when I can just yell for them to stop.
My parents screamed bloody murder at each other all the time. Cussed at each other, called each other horrible names. Slammed doors and stomped around the house. I never invited anyone over because I was so embarrassed. My mother was abusive and often times would target ME so I especially didn't want to have friends over for that reason. Also, they yelled when they disciplined my brother and me. It was horrible.
My opinion is that yelling isn't okay. Occasionally, parents will lose their temper and might raise their voice but I'm of the firm belief that you should treat kids with respect in order to get their respect. Respect has no room for YELLING. I will not yell at my children. It was ineffective for me, it was ineffective for my brother and did nothing but give us self esteem and authority problems. I don't want my children to grow up thinking that yelling at someone is an appropriate way to communicate disapproval or anger.
To this day, I can't handle someone raising their voice at me. It gives me anxiety.
I plan on being a gentle disciplining parent. No yelling, no spanking, and rarely giving time outs. Kids will be kids. They are suppose to rebel. They are suppose to question. They are suppose to push your buttons and test boundaries. It's my job as a parent to explain, educate, and nuture... not to scare or harm.
After reading some comments, I'll add that yelling "NO!" if they are running in to traffic or "STOP!" if they are about to do something dangerous is acceptable. Yelling as a form a discipline is unacceptable, in my opinion.
All my dad ever does is yell. My siblings and I don't really bring friends over because he's got an unpredictable temper that sets off over nothing. His yelling never did much to stop us from doing things; it just made it so we started hiding eveything we did.
No, my parents didn't, and I don't plan to. It's not necessary for effective discipline.
@LadyGwenivere@xanga - This has nothing to do with the post, but I think it's awesome you adopted a couple kids :)
Anyways, My mom CLAIMS her and my dad always fought... I can only think of a few times when they did. It was mostly them fighting with my older brother... BUT.. My mom and step dad? Thats a whole different story.. They fought all the time.. Christmas sucked because there were fights (I lived with my dad but visited my mom alot.. I now live in the same country as them) Vacations sucked as well.. But, They seemed to have stopped fighting as much, but I wouldnt know too much since I dont live with them... My 2 little sisters fight all the time, but they are siblings, its more normal, lol.
@TiredSoVeryTired@xanga - I totally did that today. They were chasing and teasing each other slamming doors and I yelled at them to stop from the shower. LOL!
@sarahsmurfette@xanga -
My family had/has a lot of problems I never realized until now that I'm an adult. As a kid I just accepted the fact my parents yelled a lot, and I had to deal with it. It's weird to think back that I was never really upset about what my parents did, and just accepted it as normal when nobody else did it.
There has always been a lack of respect though, that's for sure. I always thought it was a typical parent-child relationship, they can do whatever the fuck they want and I have to follow their rules. I'm 21 years old and if I upset my mom over something trivial, I still get sent to my room without being allowed to make supper. I shower when she says I'm allowed and I have to be careful flushing the toilet after 9pm.
I can understand where my moms boyfriend gets it, his entire family is just extremely loud all of the time, mostly deaf and drunk. But my mom's the only person on her side of the family that ever yells. I've heard my grandmother yell less than ten times in my life, and my aunt and uncle have always used respectful conversation to dicipline their kids... so I don't understand where my mom got it from.
I felt a little better lately because me and my moms boyfriend were outside the other day and two little girls drove by on bikes and sped right up while saying, "hurry, that's where the mean lady lives!". I don't know if they hear her yelling at her boyfriend and me, or if it's just when she's outside screaming at our dog (who's never been trained to listen, of course) all hours of the day.
@bmillerssailor@xanga -
I think my parents behaviour has made me feel a lot like you do. Although, I'm mostly terrified to ever have kids because I don't want to treat another human being like my mother treated me and people always, ALWAYS, tell me that, "you'll become your mother some day!" but if I ever change my mind, I really want to be kind, understanding and respectful... and keep my kids away from my mother.
Yes my mom yelled. And I hated it. I don't. Well I did for a little bit when I was pregnant with my youngest and it made me sick to my stomach and I had to work on it. Thankfully back to no more yelling.
My dad yelled. A lot, especially at my younger brothers. It never worked with them, and I learned pretty quickly what not to do if I didn't want to get yelled at. My mom rarely got angry, let alone yelled. If she did get angry with us for some reason (it had to be a HUGE reason), she sat us down and explained why, and then punished us appropriately.
And to be honest, we all respect my mom much more than we do my dad. My brothers and I regularly ignore my dad, simply because he STILL yells at us when he gets angry (I'm 28, and my brothers are 22 and 19) and I for one refuse to put up with his behavior. I have my own home, and I refuse to be treated like I'm 15 all over again. He recently found out that I engage in an activity that he doesn't agree with, and when I saw him this weekend he started yelling at me, and I had to stop him in his tracks, explaining AGAIN that I am an adult and his behavior isn't going to fly with me. Shutting him down can be aggravating, especially when I have to keep reminding him, but I refuse to be treated like shit for something that he has no say in. Can he have an opinion? Sure. Does he need to yell at his almost 30 year old daughter? Absolutely not.
Because of all that, I refuse to yell at my (future) children. I refuse to let them feel the same way my brothers and I felt. I refuse to put them thru the self esteem and confidence issues I had as a direct result of my dad's yelling. Obviously there are certain situations where yelling is appropriate, such as when they are putting themselves in imminent danger (stepping out into the street, rough housing around a lit stove, etc.), but other than that, I will treat my kids like human beings, deserving of respect. Will kids misbehave? Obviously. They're kids, pushing boundaries is how they learn what is and is not acceptable behavior.
However, our reaction to their behavior is drastically important. Treating your child with disrespect by yelling at them in anger will teach them that yelling is acceptable behavior, which it (clearly) is not. You have to punish bad behavior or they will think they can get away with it, but yelling does nothing but reinforce poor behavior. Explaining why their behavior is unacceptable is far more effective than yelling at them, and it teaches them to handle difficult situations in a far more effective manner than yelling and bullying people.
of course if we were bad as kids.
The neighbours which used to live next door to us before they split up had a son who was good friends to I was 11 and throughout the secondary school especially when I was 14 and 16 he decided to have band practise at his house. really annoyed us, but after secondary school he grew up and became fine with us.
Towards the end of his mum and dad married they used to row and yell a lot, bang doors, played loud music. Nor even mention about his dad and new partner as they moved out pretty quickly,
My mom yelled, a lot. That was her thing. I grew up with it so i was used to it, and thankfully my friends never really mentioned it. She tried not to yell in front of my friends or company though, so i know she was aware of it. My sister yells a lot as well, shes just like my mom so it comes as no surprise. My dad however is totally different, he's very quiet and hardly ever yells. If he's too quiet, you know he's mad. I'd say i'm more like my dad. I yelled when i was a teenager, but then again i think most teens do. But now that i'm older i really don't raise my voice unless i have to.
Being a mom didn't change it either, i still don't yell. It's hard for me to even be stern or firm with my voice when it comes to my son. Maybe my moms yelling cause me to be this way? I'm not sure. I don't think yelling is totally bad though, some people just do it without thinking. But too much yelling and fighting can cause harm.
@thatkyliegirlx@xanga - I was like you at one point. I got told the same thing. But guess what? I am NOTHING like my mother. I think people like us can be very lucky to have the experience we had. We didn't get shown the RIGHT way to raise children, but we got shown what NOT to do and we can take our parenting in the completely opposite direction.
My mom use to not yell. Then she made a friend and saw that she yelled at her kids a lot... somehow that got my mom into the loop and so my mom started to yell a lot. Ranting, mostly. My dad wouldn't yell until he was at his limit, and my siblings and I could always tell because his face would get hard and he wouldn't move any facial muscle for a long while. Then he'd yell and maybe throw some things around.
I use to not yell. I got into my mom's loop and started yelling though. I haven't yelled in a while, but my parents and siblings say otherwise... I think they think I "yell" when I have a whine-y voice that goes higher or lower than my normal voice.
Yes, there's yelling in our house. And it's almost always unnecessary, undeserved, overwhelming, and hurtful.
@thatkyliegirlx@xanga - I completely understand this and feel the same way myself :/
There was always a lot of fighting, both physical and verbal between my parents and siblings growing up. I would sit in my room and play with my toys trying to ignore all the screaming. Til this day, when I'm yelled at, I don't know how to react but want to hide in my room again. I completely shut down. I don't like yelling and I never yell myself. There are better ways to make your point.