Thursday, 01 September 2011

  • Mother Sued For "Bad Mothering"

    A few days ago I was listening to my morning radio show. In one segment the men were sharing a few news stories they found on the Internet. Here is one that nearly had me spitting out my Banana Nesquik.

    You can find the original article here, but I can save you a few clicks by giving a summary here.

    Two siblings who were raised in a very wealthy neighbourhood, ages 20 and 23, tried to sue their mother for "bad mothering" and "emotional distress". So what was it that this *terrible* mother did to them?

    • Didn't send her son care packages at college
    • Didn't buy the Homecoming dress her daughter wanted
    • No cash or cheques in birthday cards
    • Giving her son an "offensive" card because it suggested he was unique and one-of-a-kind
    • Called her daughter at midnight one Homecoming, making her come home
    • Not spending enough money on toys when they were younger
    • Calling the son to make sure he was wearing his seatbelt

    They wanted to sue her for $500,000. Their lawyer was their father, who had divorced the mother about 16 years ago. The father argued that his clients weren't out to get money from the mother, but instead make the mother accountable for her bad mothering. Thankfully, the judge had common sense and dismissed the case.

    I don't really like to use the f-word in my posts, but I need to use it now.

    WHAT. THE.

    "Bad mothering" because she tried to teach her children that happiness doesn't necessarily come in every single luxury and item you want mommy to buy for you? Because she cares about your safety? And you think you can SUE her for it? And what the hell is the "emotional distress" these brats endured?

    Should I be scared when I eventually have a family of my own? Should I be scared that if I don't give my children every single penny I have that they would sue me because I wasn't "giving them enough" and "being a bad mother"? How am I supposed to raise my children when I could possibly be sued by them? 

    I got birthday cards from my mother with no money and I didn't care - I more loved the sentiments she wrote in them. I never begged my mother to buy me something out of our means. I never cared how much something cost - in fact, I always tried to be frugal if my mother asked me if I wanted something. I have always been obedient to my mother and father. I follow curfews. Even now, at the age of 22, I still obey any rules my parents have because I live with them - the "my house, my rules" thing kicks into play. Heck, I have never even raised my voice to them or swore in front of them. My parents are WONDERFUL and I can't think of a single thing they did wrong when they raised me and my younger sister.

    I am so disgusted with today's society. I just... ugh. It sickens and saddens me when I read articles upon articles of people suing for the stupidest reasons. Another example: I heard a story that a woman was driving a minivan down the wrong way on a freeway in the middle of the night, and she caused a massive accident. She killed a few people. her husband is now suing the Dept of Transport for not having signs on the FUCKING FREEWAY saying "wrong way". And there are dumber stories being created every day.

    I'm afraid to live in today's world. I'm scared to find out how messed up society will be when it's time for me to raise my own family. I don't know if I want to live in such a fucked up place anymore. I'm considering moving to an isolated little cottage in the middle of nowhere so I don't have to be surrounded by such a crappy society.

    For Fun: What "bad mother" things would your children ever try to sue you for?

Comments (11)

  • wyrdkismet@xanga

    i am really baffled why this was even a case

  • dinguyen@xanga

    wow. that's pathetic of the kids.

  • Xcite_Media@xanga

    The rotten brats should be sued for being ungrateful to a parent and for trying to rob her of money and dignity.

  • Brilliant_Innocence@xanga

    If that's what they call "emotional distress", they need to get down on their knees and thank God for the life they had! Spoiled brats.

  • StatelessPilot@revelife
    Honestly, we don't know the deeper issues at hand so maybe the lawsuit is justified. Who knows? I'd have given anything to sue my father's ass off, but he died a slow and painful death, which I played a part of (by refusing to donate an organ, thus saving my career but essentially killing him). With as terrible of a father as he was, that was more satisfying than getting money out of him ever would be.

    That said, if he were still alive today, I'd be suing his ass off for 23 years of emotional distress and the cost of some medical equipment which I needed to undo the greatest injustice which he perpetrated against me.

    However, I love my mother dearly and wouldn't dream of suing her for anything. She's stood by me through thick and thin, the good times and the bad, and stood up for me and defended me when nobody else would. My mother is the most amazing person on the face of this planet, bar none. I love her and I know she loves me and 100% supports me in everything I do, not to mention she bends over backward to help me out. She's Incredible and I couldn't imagine my life without her. ILY, mom! <3
  • filtered_sunlight

    *face palm* The ex-husband sounds like he should be ashamed of himself and grow the fark up! Bitter about paying alimony to your ex much? Yeeeaaahhh. Dummy.

    My kids...could sue me for not taking them to Disney every week or letting them eat unlimited cup cakes, I suppose. And some days? The 9 year old sounds like he just might do that! Last year, he went to school and bitched to his teach that, "All [I] do for [him] is keep a roof over [his] head, food on the table and clothes on [his] back"! In a rare moment of sensibility for that particular teacher, she pointed out that that was quite a lot, actually, and wasn't he just busted the week before for having his DSi in school?? I could have kissed her! LMAO

  • bbanmen420@xanga

    Dont be scared about having kids like that.. Most kids aer not like that... Those kids sound really spoiled or something and ungratful..... I cant believe it... My parents didnt even give me money for college let alone care packages.. WTF??

  • bbanmen420@xanga

    @filtered_sunlight -  LOL that made me laugh :P Thats ALL you do?? Hahahaha... People need to be grateful for having a roof over their heads/food/clothes... Heh, Dsi :P

  • millionofstars@xanga

    Wow. This is a senseless case where nothing makes sense. I think this is a good mother to her kids. Whereas the father is the one who wants to make noise. Of course I do not know the story of the mother and the father, but it seems she is better off without him.

  • PervyPenguin@xanga

    The U.S needs to make hitting kids with the metal-end of the belt legal.

  • dream_guru5@xanga

    If it was WV, they would have won the law suit.  We have so many pointless lawsuits and so many stupid people get money from them it's pathetic. 

    Those kids sound beyond spoiled, when I saw the title, I thought it would be more a case of neglect than watching out for safety and so on.  At least they called the girl at the dance, in 11th grade my dad came into the dance and came into the WOMEN'S bathroom and drug me out.  All because I forgot to tell him I was staying after the game and going to the dance and he waited in the cold for 1 hour on me to come to the car.  That's more "emotional distress" but I'd never sue him over it and noone ever said anything to me about it.  Those kids need to get over whatever they were mad about.  It was all pointless and the exhusband needs to grow up.  Stupid lawsuits out of grudge aren't the adult thing to do.

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

Who recommended?