Monday, 30 November 2009

  • Roughhousing, Fun or Dangerous?

     

    Some little kids just love to play rough.  The little guys I watch are two of those kids.

    It is hilariously entertaining to watch the 16-month-old grab his two-year-old brother (who is twice his size!) around the waist and pull him down to the ground.  Once he has him pinned on the floor he will almost always proceed to climb on top of his brother as if he is some victorious warrior determined not to let his enemy escape.

    Both boys will be cracking up while all of this wrestling is taking place.  Then, BAM! Someone hits a head, or somebody’s foot accidentally finds someone's face.  

    And then the fun is done.  Inevitably, this is where I rush over to the scene, scoop whoever is crying up and treat whatever battle wound he may have with an icepack and maybe some fruit snacks. 

    So here is the issue, do we (mom, dad, me-the caretaker) allow the boys to wrestle at all? 

    Obviously, it is up to the parents to decide whether or not the boys should be playing like this, I am just there to enforce whatever rules they decide fits their family best.  However, the parents are split at the moment on this particular matter.

    One parent thinks the boys should be allowed to wrestle.  The idea behind letting them play rough is that they will either toughen up a bit or put a stop to this type of play themselves. The other parent fears the children getting hurt and likes to put a stop to this behavior before it ends in booboos and tears. 

    I think both parents have valid arguments.  Right now, since a decision has not been reached on whether or not this type of play is ok, I usually let them wrestle for a little while.  I watch the boys closely, making sure there is nothing around that they could break or bang into and get hurt.  The second I notice that one boy is no longer having fun I put a stop to the play by coming up with another fun activity everyone can safely enjoy.

    So what do you think, let the boys play rough and wrestle, or discourage this behavior?

Comments (14)

  • TheNumberScott@xanga

    Good question. The booboos aren't really a big deal for me, as much as them learning that hitting and wrestling are okay forms of play, and what they will do when they're angry. They may have a hard time realizing that although your brother doesn't mind getting pushed over, the kid at the playground might.


    Although, I don't want them to be complete pansies.


    I actually think the way you're currently handling it is probably the best way to go.


    (btw, love how you try to hide which parent is which)

  • Shy___Away@xanga

    I don't see any problem with roughhousing. Kids will play rough, but if you instill in them early on what sort of behavior is appropriate, and what's not (like, boys aren't allowed to punch each other in the balls, hair pulling is off limits,etc) they'll not seriously hurt each other.

  • TornadoChaser

    I don't have any problems with my three boys wrestling/play fighting as long as they do it in safe place i.e usually outside on the grass or in their playroom (when it's clean...). If it gets too rough, we make them take a break for a little bit. With my guys there's no stopping it anyway so we try to just make it as safe as possible for them.


  • Erika_Steele@xanga

    let them play, but set boundaries teach them how to play fair and to be safe

  • XxFireXboltxX@xanga

    I think rough-housing is an important part of growing up. My son is going to be six months old next week and his daddy LOVES to get on the floor and roll around and play rough with him. I know wrestling will be encouraged in our household and I will be there to kiss the bumps and bruises away. As long as kids are supervised, I think it should be allowed.

  • Fairywife@xanga

    My 18 month old daughter just walked up to her daddy and punched him in the arm today, telling him she wanted to wrestle (aka daddy grabs her and starts tickling her). It was pretty funny. 

  • filtered_sunlight

    I've put a stop to it because the boys are older (7 & 9) and it was getting way too rough as well as the 7 year old having issues with aggression. Recently, their dad put it to a stop as well...they were coming back injured (to the point where the 9 year old's knee seriously could have used stitches, but their father won't take them to the hospital or doctor, period, and by the time I picked them up from him, it had already been more than a day and pretty well closed on it's own...only to be reopened when he bumped it a week later...like I said; it should have had stitches) EVERY single weekend that they were at daddy's and more than half of the afternoons spent at his house (also worth noting, they typically were *not* supervised, so I'm sure that added to that problem). I also don't want them being rough with Megan as they have 6 & 8 years and quite a bit of weight on her...and, like I said, they do not know when to stop. So, in our case, it fell into the "dangerous" column and has been discontinued.

  • sinpescado@xanga

    I allow a very small amount of horseplay - the boys are 4 and 5 1/2 - around here.  Usually mine reach the point where it's no fun long before any actual injury occurs.  We did have one trip to the ER for a head injury due to the younger pushing the older into the corner of the bed.  Honestly, they could have done that alone - having a brother just made it easier to get hurt!  :)


    To some extent, I think my boys need the physical outlet but we do encourage less of the horseplay and more things like running outside or playing hide and seek. Those tend to be less dangerous and are more socially acceptable when they try to play with friends. The thing I want to avoid is having one of my boys take what to them is a friendly game to a friends house, school, or McDonalds and have someone else get very upset.  I've had too many instances when bigger boys have obviously been allowed to wrestle each other and don't understand that other kids or smaller kids may not know how to play their rough games. 


    Basically, we allow a little wrestling/horseplay but keep it to a minimum right now because they don't know enough social conventions to keep them from taking their horseplay to inappropriate places.

  • tracezilla@lovelyish

    Oh for goodness sake. I think that not allowing boys to play this way is just being overprotective. Children get owies all the time, its part of being a kid. There's nothing wrong with making sure this occurs in an area where there are very few or no things for them to smack their heads on, but stopping the play all together is just unnecessary and ridiculously over protective. :/

  • PenaltyLife@xanga

    if they started wrestling without anybody teaching them it's fun or right, then there's obviously a reason. males have more testosterone. they have to fight, at least a little bit. it's human nature, something that helped us as a species survive.

    let them do it, because they're supposed to do it. but don't let one of them become a bully.

    hell, i'm a girl and i think i did stuff like that sometimes, too.

  • FIFA_World_Cup_2010@xanga

    This is the exact situation I'm going through now. I nanny two boys (6 & 3), and the 3-year-old always likes to grab his brother and start roughhousing. As long as they aren't making TOO much noise, I let them go on, but sometimes, as is expected, someone gets hurt, and the fun stops. But the 3-year-old grinds his teeth, and I know when he does he's getting extra aggressive, but it usually doesn't escalate that bad. 

  • leannenannette@xanga

    I don't see a problem with roughhousing.

  • jkl338804
  • smgcrossfire@xanga

    I don't see a problem with roughhousing. Kids have been doing it since the dawn of time. My parents just sat back and watching my bothers and I go at it until someone got hurt, then they'd just say that that's what you get for messing around. We learned in due time that if you don't want to get hurt, you shouldn't fight. Of course for us that just meant that we didn't cry anymore when we got hurt, because stopping our wrestling matches were unheard of. I personally think there's nothing wrong with rough play.

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About the Author

  • michcoy@xanga
    • From: michcoy@xanga
    • Name: Michelle
    • About Me: I am a full-time nanny who loves to write whenever I can. I also love being outdoors whenever possible. Camping, hiking and kayaking are a few of my favorite activities.
    Stats: This Week All Time
    Posts: 1 61
    Views: 59 32463
    Comments: 7 877
    View all posts by michcoy@xanga

Who recommended?