Tuesday, 03 November 2009
-
One-Upmanship: Do Parents Own Bragging Rights?
It is called "one-upmanship." Have you noticed how all parents seem to be in constant competition amongst each other to be a one-upper?
I was at one of those crazy Halloween parties the other day with a bunch of strangers. It was a party at the community clubhouse. While the unsuspecting kids got high on sugar and ran around I joined some of the parents intent in conversation. The parents were exchanging notes, about the accomplishments of kids. They talked about the grades at school, the different activities their kids did, how polite and well mannered they were. What one mom said, the other one could most definitely top.I stood there awe struck and wondered where I had landed in this room of super moms with geniuses for kids! Meanwhile a couple of the kids ran through the group screaming out their lungs and hope was restored!
Needless to say, it was soon my turn to brag! And I was fumbling to find something to say...my thoughts went back to my mother. I grew up in an extremely competitive society. Asians and more specifically Indians can be like that, they expect their kids to excel in their grades and grow up to be a professional - doctor, engineer, and so on...nothing less works for them! My parents were equally ambitious for us too, however when they spoke to their friends they constantly underplayed our achievements. As a result I am sure many of them thought we were dim wits, and I know for a fact that one of them spoke to me slow and clear to make sure I understood! Oh well!
Back to reality, I was now really worried. It was time to stand up for my son and brag about his capabilities, it was time to prove he was no dim wit. Instead I stood at loss for words. Sure my son did well at school, sure he was mostly a very sweet little child, sure he loved his sports. However I hadn't yet signed him up for the myriad activities and classes outside school yet, because (gasp!) I did not want to overwhelm him!
He had a love-hate relationship with school and his homework. He loved when they were done, but hated them when he was asked to do them! But I had not given much thought to any of his so called accomplishments yet! He was a child! He would blow hot and cold every other day. When I thought he was this sweet little kid, he would yell and throw a tantrum! But then I know that would pass too and I would get my big hug! So what do I brag about?
I was saved my chance when my son walked up to me and pulled my hand till he had my ear "Mommy can we please go home now, I don't really like this party"! I smiled and told the others "I think he is overwhelmed with all the people here" and I left leaving a group of parents snickering behind!
My take? Unless we let our children be children, they are going to grow up into very stressed individuals. Don't worry about upping the next kid, enjoy the innocent childhood and marvel at their creative ability for yourself. Each child is unique and has to be appreciated for himself/ herself. And now is the time to rethink those bumper stickers -" My son is a honor student" so?
What is your take on one-upmanship? Do you think bragging about kids is a problem or a right?
Post a Comment
- Back to momaroo's Momaroo Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in momaroo's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)















Comments (14)
Neither. I haven't encountered, well, any of it, really. Maybe I've been lucky. Maybe it's the people that I choose to surround myself with. Maybe it's the sheer fact that different kids do things at different times with different degrees of sucess and I'm not personally bothered by others mentioning the things that their children have done.
In a situation like you described, moms have very little else to talk about except their kids. And when you talk about your kids, naturally you tend to brag. I think it's just natural for parents. As long as it doesn't get nasty or leave anyone feeling inadequate as a parent, I think it's fine.
You're right though, sometimes you just want to say: "give it a rest, lady! All kids grow up at different rates, I couldn't care less that your 6-month-old is fatter than mine!"
Nice post :)
I think all Moms brag- we can't help it! And it's not to say "My kid is better than yours." It's just exciting to see kids grow and go through milestones. I understand what you're saying about the parents who are trying to raise overachievers though... it's usually an insecurity on their part.
@Nina1981@xanga - I think you're right about it being an insecurity in those instances. I would think that most parents see their children as extensions of themselves - and therefore the self-serving bias extends to the children. We see what we want to see in our kids, just like we see what we want to see in ourselves. It's a psychologically natural tendency acting as a pretty effective defense mechanism to keep us optimistic and happy with ourselves - so, insecurity? Sure, I guess technically to some degree, but not necessarily with all of the negative connotation it carries.
I think it's okay to say "My kid's doing this, and we're really proud of him" but it shouldn't be a competition.
All kids are different, and we'd have it no other way.
My favorite bumper sticker about kids says "I love my child whether or not they're an honor student."
I loved the words from that bumper sticker too Mistress Aislin. It is not so much the talking about the kids.. I can live with that, I quit my corporate job to spend more time wiht my son. My son only started 5 day school this year. He has been going to 3 day school the past couple of years. So my life actually does revolve around my child and I am very proud of him. However I am not in constant competition to showcase him among other kids or their moms! Sometimes when that happens, the parents start to live their child's life and push and prod them to do more than necessary or normal. And this is kind of one-upmanship can be detrimental to the child. It is important to remember that every child is an individual and unique and appreciate him/her for their unique capabilities and not how they compare with others their age.
I try not to brag, because well..it's annoying! I've learned that people actually notice how smart my daugther is on their own. (She actually is advanced). And when they bring it up I say "Yeah.." and then talk about how she knows sign language, talks in full sentences, etc etc. I try to keep it to minimum. But, hey, if they're curious, I might as well tell! lol.
I've seen 2 very different outcomes to parents openly bragging about their children. On the one hand, I've seen these kids grow up being told they are better than their peers. As a result, they feel that they deserve things for being better, even without doing anything to earn it. They lack the understanding that most things in life must be worked towards and earned, even if you are the best.
On the other hand, there are the kids who see the pedestal their parents have put them on and feel like the expectations are too high, feeling inadequate. These are the kids who brake under the pressure and never really achieve all that they can.
Both are sad situations that lead to a lot of heartache and stress for our kids. I think as parents it's our job to set realistic goals for them, ones that will require hard work and practice but are still within their personal abilities.
i see nothing wrong with putting a bumper sticker on your car that says your child is an honor student, or talking about their achievements, it just means you're proud of them. straight up bragging though, i think is a problem. especially if the kids have a good relationship between them.
for one, parents are supposed to be role models. bickering and bragging with/to each other are childish things to do, and if a kid sees their parent do it, they'll think it's okay.
for two, it could strain the relationship between the kids. "well YOUR mom called MY mom this and this and this and said that her kid was way better!" is not exactly a highlight in a friendship.
I don't think its wrong to brag about your child, if you feel you have something to brag about. But, people who do need to realize that they can come off as pompous or annoying. :p
I think there's a lot of embellishing that goes on with that kind of thing, too. So, not all of the bragging is probably true and what is should probably be taken with a grain of salt, just because its probably embellished to make it seem like it was more than it is. :p
As for the bumper stickers, I see nothing wrong in publicly showing your pride for your child. In a case like that, I don't feel its one-upping, because its just random people who will see your bumper. Usually when you try to impress people, its if you care about their opinion, and why would anyone care about the opinion of someone you will never likely meet in person beyond a "hey" or a nod as you get out of the car to head into a building. Even then, most people don't pay attention to the others in the parking lot if they don't know each other. :p Driving down the road, nobody cares. I think in the case of the bumper stickers, at least, its just simply showing that you are proud of your child. And that doesn't automatically constitute trying to one-up anyone.
I never EVER talk about my children to other people (excluding their teachers for progress.) I find people who constantly talk about how awesome their kid(s) is/are are tedious bores who have accomplished so little in their lives that they are trying to use their kids (and their [real or imagined] accomplishments) to bolster their own egos.
From what I've seen, most other people's kids are brats. Even they seem to think so, You can tell how they really feel when you walk past their homes and hear them screaming at the tops of their lungs at their precious little darlings... No matter how much they brag in public.
I know my kids can be brats. They have their good points, too, just like any other human being. I, however, do not need to use them to make myself feel better about myself or more superior to other parents or people.
I say to braggart parents: "So you have a child who made the honor roll at Blah-Blah Middle School? Congrats to them! What have YOU done lately? Life didn't stop when you became a parent, did it?"
@MissHollywoodStarlet@xanga - well said!! :)
I have a very large extended family... everytime they get together it seems like everyone is trying to out do each other's kids. It's so rediculous. My second cousin Lauren and her husband badly managed their money by refinancing their house twice just because they had to havenew ashley furnature, granite countertops, a pool, and a taller privacy fence. Well they ended up loosing their house. Instead of saying that or just sayin nothing they bragged about "getting" the opportunity to move to another area a little closer to the auto shop her husband works at. They are the same way with her kids. Her daughter Kaylee has ADHD and got kicked out of her daycare because of her behavior, and once again Lauren and her husband bragged about their daughter being so out going and energetic that they decided to put her in another daycare where her "full potential will be realized".
I think if your child has actually done something like gotten on the honnor roll or had their team win a championship it's ok to talk about it, bu streatching the truth is not ok.
Lace Wigs
Wedding Dresses