Wednesday, 21 October 2009

  • Trouble With In Laws

    Trouble With In Laws
    image source

    This post was long in the making. Over the last several years I have been struggling with my in-laws. They are lower middle class and live with the idea that they have to look like they are upper class because they're from older money, of which they no longer have. I am tired because I am from lower class life. My parents were immigrants from Hungary and Mexico. My family has always struggled with money even though in Hungary they were wealthy from the whiskey they made. So here these people are judging me constantly. They want to see their grandchild so badly that they are willing to pay for rental cars for us to come and visit them several states away. That's great, but even when we did come to visit them they set rules that directly address their authority over me and how I'm not really worth their time, money, or space. I have a disability and they absolutely are prejudiced against me for it. I as a parent watch my child on my own, am able to drive to do errands and what not, and have lived my whole life, on my own, but now that they are in my life, I suddenly am not allowed to be capable to even take care of my child on my own.

    I have been told I am not allowed in their house by myself, because I am not capable to taking care of my son in an emergency or even in normal circumstances. That I am not allowed to drive with my child alone because they don't feel comfortable with it, and that is just what was said to my face. I was told my my spouse that when they approached their parents about marriage to me, the response was that we should avoid it because I was thought to be "half of a person" and "too needy!"
    I've overheard argument between the parents and my spouse about how I am trying to sabotage the work aspects for us because I am just lazy and don't want to have us have to go to work. Instead, in their minds, I am just wanting to sit on government programs, getting a handout, and keep us both at home so we can be lazy.

    All this, and they still send us nice little packages in the mail, try calling us all the time to "talk", and beg us to come up for holidays. I am so tired of feeling this way. I have decided not to go for any more of these holiday excursions and not to accept anymore of these packages. My husband can do anything he wants, but I am going to stick with my family because they have proved that they will love me no matter what. My spouses family has proved they will love my spouse no matter what, but when I have a need they are quick to say sorry, we don't feel comfortable helping you!

    I seriously feel no burden to "honor" their obviously twisted view of who I am. I am a burden to them, a hindrance to their child and grandchild, and am not welcome with my problems or needs. If my spouse were to die, I truly believe I would not be welcome in their home. I would fear them trying to take our child because they truthfully believe I am incapable of caring for myself, let alone our child! Does this deserve honoring in any way? The Bible says you should obey when you are a child, and honor when you are an adult, but do you think Christ would really promote such behavior being followed? Do you think he would WANT me to become what they want me to be?

    All that being said, I ask you this... Have you ever had really big problems with your in-laws, or even your own birth/adoptive parents, that made you consider cutting the ties? Do you think it is wrong to choose to do something like that? What kind of limits do you think there should be on how much parents, be they natural or in-laws, should be able to control or effect your life after you leave home and get married or live on your own?

Comments (17)

  • gwacemom

    First, I am sorry that you are dealing with such a difficult situation. I personally cut ties with my own mother for almost ten years for reasons similar to those you have mentioned.


    You are an adult, you don't mention the nature of your disability and honestly, it matters not. You obviously have no problem caring for your child in your home and should in no way be expected to relinquish that job simply because your inlaws don't "feel comfortable". Too bad so sad for them.


    I would just let them know that you will no longer be coming to visit, but that they are more than welcome to come visit your family at your home. I would also explain in no uncertain terms the boundaries and that you expect them to respect those boundaries. Good luck.

  • Cognizant_Wolf@xanga

    I compeletly understand where you are coming from.  There have been many times when I have felt like cutting the ties with my husband's dad.  His dad as always viewed me as someone who shouldn't be with his son, simply because I will not allow him to walk all over me and because I refuse to fall for his mind games.


    There has been one incident where I completely cut him off from me and my son.  When he was dating this one woman who I knew was a psycho, I let him know it and let him know I didn't trust her.  I was pregnant at the time.  Well, not long after my son was born, my father-in-law told my husband I was not allowed at his house, since I didn't like his girlfriend, but my son was more then welcome over there.  I let my husband and his Dad know, that if I wasn't welcome over there, then there was no way my son was going over there.  It remained that way for a few months, until my father-in-law removed his head from his butt. 

  • MistressAislin@xanga

    Yes, I have had problems with my in-laws, as well as my birth parents.  I have cut ties with both of them, though they have since come back into my life.  (Both have had major attitude adjustments since)  and No, it's not wrong.  You are an adult, you are responsible for your family and the health and well being of your child.  Not your in-laws.  Do what's right for you and your child.  Your parents should have 0 control over your life once you leave home, get married, and live on your own.

  • DirtyAndShaken@xanga

    I'm very lucky in that I married into a great family.  I was hesitant of my MIL at first, thinking she would be overbearing (especially with her being a retired nurse and us announcing we were planning a homebirth).  But she's a wonderful woman that is very conscious of how she approaches us and never oversteps her boundaries.  She only gives advice if asked.

    My birth mother, on the other hand, is a different story.  I cut ties with her almost 15 years ago.  She was/is an alcoholic and was very mentally and verbally abusive.  I've seen her a few times since, but she may never know her grandson.  I don't feel guilty anymore - it's how she chooses to be.

    You have every right to feel the way you do - NO ONE has the right to disrespect you in such a way.  I'm sorry that they can't see past a physical disability and see you for whom you are.  Their loss.  I know that doesn't make it any easier, but life is too short to worry about pleasing the unpleasable.

  • EnjoyEdii@xanga

    Gosh I'm sorry to hear that they are so awful to you... they not only should stop, but allow you to continue being the responsible adult.parent/spouse you ARE. I have never been married but with my ex, we were going to get married. Seriously this guy was (still is) the love of my life and once we moved to Reno from Chicago to live near his parents they did the same things to me. Only fortunately we did not yet have children. But they were the reason for my break up. They convinced him that I was a terrible person. Which I'm not btw. But they were always so nice to my face for like 5 mins then they'd switch to their language and were rude. and obviously when he was alone with them, they would talk his ear off about how awful I was.


    Just do your thing woman! you are a wonderful person!
  • a12906@xanga

    Are you sure you need to let them see your kid if they act like that? You wouldn't let your kid go out and do what he wants if he acted up, these people are clearly the same way.

  • rainbowbrite2200@xanga

    I understand, my husbands father does not approve of me, especially what is going on in our lives right now, we keep most things to a minimum and its even hard to go visit, because he always wants to butt in and tell us how we should run our life. I would suggest doing what my husband does keep contact to a minimum and let him know how you feel.

  • mixtapelovee@xanga

    I am so sorry that you have to deal with such rude and judgmental people. I wish you the best of luck with the situation.

    My husband's biological mother is schizophrenic and she tried to end his life when he was only two. Luckily, his father was smart enough to get him out of that situation and had a restraining order put against her. When my husband turned 18 the restraining order ended and he chose not to get another one, feeling that he could handle any situation that might arise with her, being that he is in the military. He chose to contact her once, because he thought maybe she might have changed. She has not and he has since ended all communications with her. He had told me he never wanted me to have to meet her and I agreed with him from the stories I have heard. Unfortunately, he is deployed right now and while I was out with someone else in his family one weekend, she showed up and I was basically forced by this other family member to meet her. She introduced herself and then preceded to tell me that I wasn't good enough for her son because I wasn't like her (why anyone would consciously want to be like her, I have no clue), and that if he ever wanted to have anything to do with her he would have to divorce me. I am fortunate enough that my husband will stand up for me to his family, no matter what.

  • Riftsong@xanga

    This is a very timely post for me.  I've been struggling with a manipulative, bipolar mother in law.  A friend recently told me a story very similar to yours.  This topic has been very much on my mind.  In my friends case I believe that the problem is mostly misunderstanding and miscommunication.  In mine the problem seems to be that my MIL is crazy.  She's not mean spirited and I doubt that she even realizes the havoc she is wreaking on our family.  I've had my moments when I've wanted to just cut ties with her.  I tell myself that I'm doing it for the good of my daughter.  But upon some deeper reflection I find that I want to end our relationship because I don't want to deal with it.  It would be easiest to just not talk to her.  What example does that set for my children though?  Family only counts when they are nice to you?  When a relationship gets difficult just get out?  I guess in the end of the day I've decided to keep trying.  I don't want my children to grow up estranged from their grandmother and she will always be my husband's mother.  It's a work in progress...

  • LisiliLostRedemption@xanga

    I'm very sorry that you have such horrible in-laws...

    It reminded me of my cousin's situation. Her parents made her boyfriend still call them by their last names after they were dating for 5 years and lived together, just because they thought he wasn't good enough for her. Luckily, she found the strength to put her foot down and demand respect.

    I hope you can find a way to deal with this. Maybe you should confront your parents-in-law openly about this situation, with your husband by your side. Even if it changes nothing, your position will be clear...

    This really puts my little quarrels with my in-laws-to-be in perspective...

  • filtered_sunlight

    I had nasty in-laws of my own...shortly after we married, they caused drama (mostly because I'm a white, non-religious, democrat to their proud Cuban, self-rightous Catholic, republican) and the husband-now-ex-husband and I ended up not speaking to them, period. The last time I was able to chat with ex, he still wasn't speaking to them because of the way that they treat people...they also treated him like a doormat on top of treating me like something that they stepped in. It's not what anyone wants, but sometimes? It has to be done.

  • tracezilla@lovelyish

    I have had issues with my mother and stepfather that have made me consider cutting all ties. I live an hour away and I barely speak to them. But, all ties have not been severed. Still, it would take very little for that to occur now.

    I don't think it is wrong of you, what your in-laws are doing is not good for you, for your spouse, for your child or for your marriage. They can believe whatever they want to believe, that's their prerogative. However, that does not mean you have to follow their wishes and whims and make yourself into an invalid for their convenience.

    You are an adult, you are married, you are capable. Even if they don't think so. They have no say over you or your child, that child is not theirs. It's good that they want to see their grandchild, but they have no right to tell you what to do. They can say what they want, and you can consider it, but that is all you need to do. And really, even that isn't necessary. They don't act like people who deserve much consideration.

    I would tell them before I go down there the next time, if I went, that things would not be going the usual way. If I wanted to go somewhere alone with my son, I would. He is mine and there is no more danger than if they were driving him around, and if they aren't comfortable with it...then I guess they just won't be comfortable.

    I would look into perhaps a motel or something for you three, mostly so that they can't insist so much that you not be alone with your son just because THEY think you aren't capable of handling it. But, that may be beyond your financial means. It might also depend on how long you stay.

    Personally, I would not at all think it would be out of line to just stop accepting packages or going down for holidays and whatnot. It would also not be out of line to make THEM make the trip to YOU to see their grandchild once in a while. They can make their own rules within their own home, but if they come to you it is your home and they may not like it but they will have to live by your rules instead. And that you just can't comfortable with them stepping all over your authority.

    Your child needs to grow up understanding that you and your husband both are the first authority, and if you both plus his paternal grandparents are there, it is you two who are the authority figures. Not your grandparents. Unless the child is staying with them without the two of you around. And that you alone are also just as much an authority figure as your husband. Otherwise, I think it will be very confusing.

  • dearFLOPPY@xanga

    well, i don't even have a disability and my SO's parents think im lazy. its ridiculous at the degree some inlaws will sink to, just to make you feel like shit. my SO and i are both straight A students in university, and just because i haven't given them a definite answer as to what i will be doing after graduation (this yr), it means im hopeless and have no goals in life. it sucks because you love your SO with all your heart, and you hate to break their family apart like that, but it does happen. i don't have any advice, but i say do what you like, and what you want. be respectful when you WANT to, because honestly, if they want respect, they need to deserve it. if they don't deserve it, don't go up there. they have to learn a lesson.

  • Sirius_Fan_Girl@xanga

    I am not married (nor have I ever been), and my boyfriend's parents are very good to me. I know that a while back in the relationship his mother said we should break up because he was going to get hurt, but she said that because he was badly hurt by his previous girlfriend and she was afraid for him. Luckily enough, she does seem to like me, and so does his father. :) Now they seem to encourage him to take me places, ahahaha. :)
    Might I ask what the disability is? What they're doing is definitely wrong, no matter what, but it would help put some better perspective on it. (I mean, they might think that it's too minor a disability to matter and that you shouldn't be getting assistance, or that you have too great a disability to care for a kid- either way, you clearly are able to care for your child because you DO, and they have no right to try and force you to relinquish your authority. If they were just making kind suggestions, it would make sense, but they are being entirely unfair. Not cool.)
    They can make their own rules for their own house, of course, but the car thing makes no sense and most (if not all) of their rules have little basis in logic.

  • momtokaynjay29@xanga

    I know exactly what your going through me and my husband and the kids live with his parents. I don't like living with them but we got no choice at this moment but hoping to move  next year. His parents always have to lecture us on something that they don't like us doing, talking to us like we are teenagers, how to save money, or just to get on our nerves. They are good when we need a babysitter when we got to go to work, but most times when my in-laws are working we got no one who can babysit for us.My parents don't live in Newfoundland they live in Quebec so that is no good. My in-laws always have to find something to complain about. Just recently I had to go visit my parents and while I was gone  my mother in-law went and reorganized  the kitchen cupboard and moving stuff around  and when I got back I had to look for where the dishes or the drinking glasses are and other stuff I was looking for. I told my husband maybe I should label each cupboard with names of the stuff that are in them.He just says yeah I should.

  • planetx@xanga

    Wow, there must be some kind of Xangan karma going around. Today I realised my breaking off a long term relationship a year ago was not the tragedy I kept feeling it was. It was a blessing because him n his fam would never have respected me or thought me good enough for their son, they essentialy were fixing him up with someone else right in front of me and he refused to see it. So just like I realised for myself today, you are wonderfull and if they choose not to see it they are missing out! It's you and your child, you will always have that. Your husband has the option of treating you like the wonderfull person you are or fall victim to his parents evil schemes, again his loss. If he does I am fairly certain you have alot of law on your side regarding your fears that the in-laws may want to take the kids. Just in case, do the research now. Protect your life.

  • jkl338802
    1
    秋天賞楓何處去酒店經紀,安排韓國旅遊有獨到心得的旅行社表示 酒店打工,秋遊韓國的重點就是美食、溫泉、還有雪嶽山美麗秋景。位於江原道 酒店兼差束草、襄陽、麟蹄一帶的雪嶽山,是韓國最早楓葉轉紅的地方,也由於雪嶽山一年四季都有奇岩絕璧 酒店兼職、溪谷瀑布等美景,吸引了許多觀光客前來旅遊。一到 酒店工作秋天,以雪嶽山的最高峰~大青峰酒店上班
    (1,708公尺)為首,雪嶽山各主要登山路線沿途的楓葉把山染 酒店上班成一片紅色的圖畫,美不勝收。


    標榜「全程無自費」,相當受旅客歡 寒假打工迎,而且價格相當平易近人,只要14500元即可成行。另外還有全程五星酒店、海陸空版的「戀戀秋濟^海陸空濟州4日」 暑假打工,同樣獨家全程無自費!緊張刺激360度噴射快艇(價值韓幣25000元)、飛天熱氣球(價值韓幣25000元) 酒店PT、海水溫泉汗蒸幕(價值韓幣8000元) 禮服酒店等,海、陸、空讓您玩的盡興也只要13900元!現在就去體驗韓國秋天的美景吧~


    驚險摩托車秀HAPPY TOWN 兼差價值韓幣12000元):表演者以機車為主,靈活的玩弄, 打工全世界只有兩組特技人員能做的高難度表演,在一個小時的演出中還有空中飛人﹑民俗雜技和大車輪 台北酒店經紀等表演,保證讓您大呼過隱,不虛此行喝酒 特技令人嘖嘖稱奇。而享譽全球的國寶級亂打秀(價值韓幣45000元),是韓國人獨創的敲擊樂表演,故事的場景是發生在廚房中,因此所謂的樂器就是就地以鍋碗等廚房交際應酬 用具敲 打出澎湃的節奏。在沒有冷場的過程裡,不需要語言您就可以清楚知道劇情粉味的發展,台上演員還會與台下觀眾互動演出,整場歡笑不斷。酒店工作



    去過的旅客都津津樂道的酒店喝酒韓文化生活體驗營」,讓您親手體驗泡菜製作,穿著傳統韓服更能體驗韓國婦女的優雅!另外,精緻好吃的韓國美食當然也不能 酒店不嚐:鮑魚太極人蔘雞、長壽麵、、黑毛豬烤肉、還有獨家特色餐「?花魚定食+五花肉+鐵板馬肉+?料」「生猛海鮮大餐」等等讓人食指大動。酒店經紀酒店經紀酒店兼差酒店打工酒店上班酒店經紀酒店小姐酒店打工酒店兼差 酒店工作 彩妝酒店經紀酒店酒店領檯 酒店公關酒店小姐 酒店兼差合法酒店經紀
  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About the Author

Who recommended?