Friday, 07 August 2009
-
Surrogacy - Should I Do It?
For those who do not know, my life has held certain grotesquely emotional difficulties the last three years (see, um, my blog). Due to things that have not been within my control occurring in my life most recently, I find myself thinking "how to make honest, easy money relatively quickly... hmmm".
Now, being a Gestational Surrogate Mother is something I've thought about off and on for a while. Basically, I would carry another couple's fertilized embryo(s) to term and give birth to their child for them. I just can't quite seem to make my mind up about it. I love helping people and what is a greater gift to a barren couple than a child? But at the same time, could I really carry a child and give birth to it only to hand it off to someone I don't really know?
There's also the personal aspect in which there is this micro-spec of me that really does miss being pregnant and would love to go through it again, though not necessarily have an infant to take care of 24/7 leading to a lack of sleep for the next two and a half years, then potty training, the diapers, looking for sitters, school and daycares...
I'm just really on the fence as I love the idea of it but am still hesitant. What are your thoughts?
Post a Comment
- Back to momaroo's Momaroo Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in momaroo's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)



True
Premium










Comments (39)
If you have doubts about whether you could give back the child, then I don't think you should surrogate. It could hurt you emotionally.
Personally, I think there are so many orphaned children who need parents, I don't really support surrogacy.
For me that would be too hard. I don't know if I could unless it was something I really believed it. AND I would only do it for someone that I knew would be the best parents...better than I am.
I think if there's any hesitation or indecisiveness, you shouldn't do it. It doesn't matter why you're not sure of the decision, but if you do become 100% then i'd go for it. I have also considered surrogacy, but because i have doubts, i have not pursued it right now.
If you were a gestational surrogate, not giving up the child would not even be an option. Genetically, it would not be your child. You'd merely be a vessel in the process and there would be zero choice in the matter because you'd have no relation to the baby in that case.
Trust me when I say that the last thing a couple seeking surrogacy would ever want to experience is a surrogate that changes her mind. The journey to surrogacy is hard enough (meaning most couples suffer from years of infertility). If you aren't 100% sure you could do it, then don't.
If you are asking for other people's opinions, then you are not ready to do it, and shouldn't. Surrogacy is something that you have to be committed to heart and soul and be able to weather others questions, comments, and opinions. The way you have written this post makes it obvious to me that you are not emotionally capable of doing it at this time.
Ok, I'm going to be the odd one so far. I think the questions/concerns you're having is totally normal in the surrogacy decision process. There is no way that women have NOT thought these things when deciding if being a surrogate is right for them. Of course you're going to wonder how you'll deal emotionally, you're human after all.
If you can make peace with these concerns- then you're ready. If you cannot make peace- if you really feel it would bother you to go through 9 months of pregnancy then hours of labor and minutes of your vagina stretching and tearing only to receive 20k for compensation- if that bothers you- then of course don't go for it.
But if you made peace- if you realize- yes of course it's hard to put your body through that and not have your own baby to care for in the end but you know you're mentally strong enough to get over it PLUS you said you don't want a baby to care for right now anyways so it is more ideal for you anyways.
It's a huge decision, so of course you dont want to take it lightly. And I think it's responsible to talk out these feelings/concerns rather than just going for it. Ultimately- it is up to you!
I would imagine that most women who are surrogates have some doubts about it. I think the fact that the child would be someone elses would help you to not be so attached to it. Regardless, it would be hard to give up any child you carried and had so close to you for almost a year.
I'd like to thank everyone who has commented so far, no matter their views. Honestly, I was looking for some devil's advocates, yays and nays and all other views besides. I'm trying to think of something I might've missed and wanted to enlist the help of others in that decision process.
Nina1981@xanga and KimisBarbie@xanga mentioned a couple things I very much appreciate, especially the validation of the human heart.
Before this decision is made I will be 100% devoted to it if I decide to go forward, of course, but thank you everyone for you comments.
Personally, I would feel like that's selling my body. That would weird me out. But if you're okay with that, it's your body.
I've actually considered it as well. I have a BEAUTIFUL baby boy and he is healthy as can be. I loved being pregnant and want another baby but we don't have the finances. I can't work because I have my son at home with me for at least another year and could do it, but there's a lot of things that could keep me from being considered. So I have decided it would be stupid to even try. I am tired of thinking that a person who is heavy must be unhealthy or if you have people in your history that have like, diabetes or something that you can't hold a child. Seriously, I had absolutely no complications and delivered with no problems. It wouldn't even be my dna, so why do they cancel out people who are not 100% perfect. I have a sleeping disorder which they have no idea if it's genetic or not, but seriously, it has no impact on the baby because my genes aren't part of the process! Regardless, I'd rather in some ways not bother only because it would be a burden to a poor couple who is already worried about someone else carrying their child. I'd do it though. If they would let me. lol
@Lady_Kelacy@xanga - Its a hard choice to make. Carrying a child to full term and not feeling any emotional attachment whatsoever will be hard on you. I believe you can do it, and the money would be good. But from our talks and what not, I feel that now, nor anytime in the short-term future would be a good time. I think that in order to pull through with this would require a certain lack of emotions. OR, you would have to stay focused 110% on the benefit. and I'm not talking about monetary. Just stay focused and the good deed. Honestly, I thought of Army Wives Season 1.
@twosidedme@xanga - I've never seen Army Wives but the "good deed" aspect of it is part of why I'm so drawn to do it now. Something needs to balance out the evil in this world and the only thing I have to do that with is me.
i'm a single mom and have a beautiful 3 and 1/2 y/o son. i LOVED being pregnant (yeah, there are some things that i didn't enjoy about it...lol), and with my son being that age, I really want to start having more. i'm struggling with money right now (not really bad, but relying on my parents for some money each month for rent). of all the things i have tried to do to get extra income in (selling jewelry, college books, etc), that's one thing that never occured to me. i honestly don't know how i would ever be able to carry a baby for 10 months and then go through the birthing process only to hand off him/her to the parents. it's a selfless act of love, but i don't think i'd be able to handle it.
in my opinion, have you seriously taken time to sit down and write up a pros/cons list. to be 100% honest with yourself and maybe find out the biggest reason that you want to do this. is it only for the money? is it because you want to be pregnant again? this is such a big decision and i just want you to feel that in the end you made the right choice.
good luck with whatever decision you make!
Have you considered being an egg donor first? That's what a woman I used to babysit did and it helped her to realize that she could be a surrogate and she ended up being a surrogate several times, & loved it each time.
Being a surrogate is definately not something to be taken lightly. First, money should not even be a consideration to want to do this. Having a baby in your belly for 10 months and not keeping it is something you should be emotional ready for if you have been on an emotional rollercoaster for a while maybe you should consider other options that can help people and allow you to make money. Donating your eggs, bone marrow, blood...
Giving life is the ultimate gift and very selfless to give your body away to a couple for 10 months. A couple things I would think of are if you are completely finished having children yourself. This may help you be in the right state of mind. Also I would seek advice from a professional that is unbiased to see if you are emotionally responsible.
Good luck to you and whatever decision you make will be the best for you and your family
I can't say I haven't thought about it as well. I'm in a good place to do something like that: healthy, have three kids of my own (so handing one over might not be too difficult), have good natural births without complications... my chiro actually said to me once, "It seems your body loves having babies!" (when he went to adjust me after my third birth and I didn't need an adjustment... though it was less than 48 hours after a long labor so i think i almost slapped him...)
I just hesitate on the part where I have to mess with my hormones through the pregnancy. I wasn't a happy pregnant woman. To put my family through that and then not even have the baby at the end...? I'm not sure. But I haven't gotten serious about it... maybe I should. Talk it over with the hubs. :)
Obviously you aren't ready to commit yourself to doing this since you are hesitant. Only when you are VERY SURE of yourself and truly want to do this sort of thing should you go ahead with the idea. You need to do it based on what YOU feel, not on others' opinions.
I myself offered to be a surrogate for a best friend a few years ago. She and her husband had been dealing with infertility issues for quite a long time. She did become pregnant twice (in between trying a couple of treatments, so they essentially became pregnant on their own) but suffered miscarriages.
I discussed my idea with my friend. I was so ready to do this... but then when I spoke to my ob/gyn, the idea was immediately shut down. My pregnancy hx was complicated -- I had a miscarriage in '98, then did go on to have two children, though I was high-risk. Emergency c/sections after complicated pregnancies, plus a very severe case of PPD after the birth of my daughter.
Good luck to you with whatever path you choose.
@itscatwithak@xanga - I have considered being an egg donor, but I have a genetic history of skin cancer which knocks me out, at least for the agency I've been talking with. I looked into that first, actually.
@mamaseahorse - Messing with my hormones does make me nervous as well. My first pregnancy and delivery had no complications, labor was only 8 hrs and my son was/is healthy as a horse.
@Cakeslegs@xanga - I have tthought about other avenues I coulg walk down, yes, and am considering those as well, but surrogacy has held a special place of interest in my life for a long time. Part of it is probably because I have relatives and family friends who were unble to have children who adopted, etc..
I don't think I'd be able to do this. even though it would be totally someone elses child, I wouldn't be able to. I don't think I'd be able to be an egg donor either, just because I'd feel weird knowing there are children out there who have half of my genes and I don't even know them....
I don't believe in intervening in reproduction. Conceive your own child naturally or adopt someone else's.
It seems like so much for so little. You could end up hurting yourself in the long run. I don't entirely support surrogacy, even though it is helpful. Can't you sell eggs instead?
I think these are normal feelings that everyone would be concerned about, I think that you would have to get to know the people that you would be a possible surrogate mother for and if you still had the personal doubts about your ability to hand the child over to them then don't do it. Although it is an amazing act of kindness even if you would be receiving money for it, you should not emotionally devastate yourself in order to give to someone else because you have children and others that rely on your emotional stability.
It is good that you are trying to see how you feel about it though, this isn't something you want to go into on a whim.
Go for it! Surrogacy is a wonderful medical breakthrough, and it will be a miracle for the child's parents.
Personally, I'm against the whole thing on moral/ethical grounds. Instead of creating life that nature doesn't want, I wish people would adopt. There are so many children already here that are in need of loving homes.
But, aside from that, I know it would destroy me to carry a child for nine months and come up empty when it's said and done. Also, it is a strain on your body (duh).
have you thought how this would affect your husband? your life with him while you are pregnant? it think it would be different if it was yours (his and yours) as you planned this out and all the changes that happen to your body and such. the things you could not do. i know how your are as a mother and i think you are an awesome mother. but when you were pregnant with your son, you were in a different time of your life.
i do feel this is a noble act on your part, but the state of your life currently would have me holding up the "no" sign. will there be a better or a more right time? i feel so.
you have so much caring and love inside you that i know that baby would grow inside as perfect a vessel as possible. i worry that you might not be able to detach yourself at the time of birth.
but if you choose to go ahead, i will give you as much support and good vibes as i possibly can.
and i know you will not do this on a whim. it will be well thought out or you would not have asked for opinions and thoughts on here.