
by
Mama Ladybug I'm sure all you mommies have seen the commercials.
"Your Baby Can Read" is an Early Language Development System that can be used as early as 3 months. Yes, you read it correctly, 3 month old babies can (as the website says) "benefit from" this product.
The order comes with a DVD set, flash cards, and flap books. In the commercials I've seen, it shows babies reading the flashcards of small words such as "Dog, Happy, and Gorilla."
So, is this too early for teaching reading?
Dr. Titzer says "Maybe the correct question is…Why should parents delay teaching a child to read when the most natural time to learn language is during the infant and toddler years?"
What do you think, is this a great opportunity to teach our children early on? Or is it pushing too hard for babies to grow up too soon?
Comments (10)
Fuu was reading fluently by the time she was three but I didn't really teach her. I was teaching some older children to read and she just learned on her own by listening and watching. I don't think I would actively try to push early reading but if it is fun for the baby I don't think it can hurt anything either.
As long as the kid is having fun, what harm does it do to stimulate her/him more? I mean, certainly it shouldn't be like reading boot camp, forcing your toddler to go through flashcards while you loom over them --but if all you're doing is incorporating more language skills into playtime, I think it'd be fine.
I just point at words as I'm reading to my daughter. And she points at pictures and I tell her what it is she's pointing at. It's a simple way of learning.
I taught myself how to read. No one was trying to buy special programs they just put me on the computer. :D
It's a good opportunity to take advantage of while they are pretty young. At first, it's just them basically mimicking what they're seeing on the video and then as they get older, they can kind of figure out the phoenetics for themselves. I am an independently contracted w/ the company that sells the product and I have a huge discount available to me...however, I'm hesitant to use it because it's a very boring program. I say it's an worthy investment if your young child doesn't watch much tv and isn't used to Dora, Backyardigans, Sesame Street, etc. or will watch anything. But if your baby is already drawn to songs, dances, animation, etc, then he/she will be extremely bored w/ YBCR and will quickly lose interest.
What I find ridiculous is people thinking they have to pay money to do the simple things that are shown in the ad. You can teach a baby those things on your own.
Just play with your child! My goodness! Really you don't have to push babies to learn if you play with them and have interesting things around them they will learn on their own in their own time! This is a waste of money!
I think children are capable of reading a lot earlier than we usually have them try it. But others are right, you don't need to spend money on this product. Spend time with your kids reading books to them and follow the words with your finger. My parents did this and I was very interested in books from an early age and reading on my own by 2 1/2. I feel bad for people who grew up without books in their house.
I've been told that I was reading by age three. I don't remember learning to read, but I do remember already reading things when I was in kindergarten, so I suppose it's true.
Personally, I don't see any harm in a child learning to read very early, if the experience is made enjoyable and the child isn't pressured. I don't believe that someone needs to purchase a "system" to teach reading to their children, though. If it is something you can do yourself, you can pass that skill on to your child without that.
I purchased the Teach Your Baby to Sign package and used it with my two youngest and they did learn. It was great to be able to communicate with seven and eight month old babies with ASL instead of by interpreting cries, instinct and guesses. I didn't buy that system to show me how to teach, though. I got it to teach me the signs. Thinking back, I could have just checked a book out of the library, but I'm not sorry!
I've read that the older a person learns communication skills (ie sign and foreign languages and reading) the easier learning other things will be once they start school. I don't remember why it was theorized that this should be so. If my two youngest are any proof of it, it's true. They're both doing exceptionally well.
Babies understand more than most people expect. It is a natural process to talk to your baby, show them things, tell them what you are doing, what you are eating. They love to hear your voice. They pick up on the sounds you make and feel safe and comfortable you are there. Reading to them is a way for them to build on those sounds and vocabulary. When you cuddle with them, hold them in your lap, read to them, it gives them that warm feeling and they are learning and hearing you. This creates a bond between mother and baby and develops their audio, visual, tactile eye, hand, coordination and love of reading. Raising Readers can be a natural process and doing it early before they are running around will make it easier for them and you. As for using the dvds, it is fine to use them for 10 - 15 minutes a day if you can't do it any other way. Reading to them and talking to them is a natural and non-stressful way to develop love of reading. I have taught, raised and seen many children who have been able to read by 3 years old, some younger. Makes life easier for them. Grandparents can get involved, aunts and uncles can read to them also. Teamwork is wonderful.