Wednesday, 07 January 2009

  • Does Birth Order Have an Influence on Your Personality?

    Mama Monkey by Mama Monkey

    Does Birth Order Have an Influence on Your Personality?

    I'm #5 of 7.  I am a generally very compliant person that does not usually like to make waves. I tend to be pretty quiet, but will speak up if I feel strongly enough about something or if somebody pushes the right button. Though I would not think it of myself, I have had many others tell me that they see me as a leader. I go my own way and generally don't let the opinions/actions of those around me change me. I, of course, would prefer to have things my way, but compromise is not beyond me (though I know I can be very manipulative sometimes and that is something I cam trying to work on).

    When I took a quiz on line, it pinned me as a first born personality - which I actually found very interesting. What are you? Your kids?

    There are a boat load of books and articles (both web and magazine) on this subject. Talking about everything from birth order determining your personality to it determining what you will do when you grow up. I look at my brothers and sisters and would have to say that some of them fit the 'type' their birth order says they would and others are completely opposite. Here are the basics of what I found.

    There are both compliant and aggressive first borns. A compliant first born is a people pleaser, craves approval, is caring and nurturing, cooperative and conscientious. The aggressive first born is a perfectionist, a natural leader, is very driven and conventional. They must have things their way and always under control. The compliant first born will 'grin and bear it' whereas the aggressive first born is much more assertive. Both types of first borns are energetic, logical, ambitious and scholarly. They often have a greater level of confidence, are patient and organized and have the confidence to dream and plan. However, they also often carry and innate fear of being dethroned, tend to be perfectionists and overachievers and can constantly worry about not being good enough. They often choose careers that are very black and white and can have a hard time with creative projects. It is common for a firstborn to be in a position of leadership (owner or boss of company) as they do not like to take orders from others.

    Middle children, as usual, seem to kind of be left in the dark - lost between their younger and older siblings ... and their personalities are often defined by their older sibling. In general, a middle child is going to be the opposite of the child before them. One can be a quiet, shy, impatient and uptight loner. While another middle child may be very outgoing, friendly, patient and laid back. Traits the two types often share include that they are flexible, diplomatic, competitive, seek a lot of attention and tend to rebel. They will often choose careers that allow them to be creative and don't like strict rules. They want to be able to complete things on their own time-line. They can make good management material because they are generally very level-headed.

    Then there are the last born children. Research says that they are often the easiest to pick out. They tend to be risk takers, idealists, immature, secretive and sensitive. They seek a lot of attention, have a good sense of humor and are hard working. But they can also be very spoiled, manipulative and self-centered. Many end up in careers that involve selling something and generally work better alone as they like to do their own thing at their own pace. They are more likely to feel lost and, as a result, try to hard to impress those around them.

    Of course, this is not all there is to who we are. There are countless other things that shape us as we go through out lives. But, looking at these general descriptions, do you fit your birth order type? What about your kids? Does this explain some of their behaviors? I know my oldest and middle children, right now, fit these descriptions pretty much to a 'T'.

Comments (10)

  • ELIZerson@xanga

    I admit it, I'm the typical firstborn.
    That's pretty much all there is to it.
    It all has to do with how you were raised, though.
    My mom was a third and last child.  However her closest sibling agewise was fourteen years older than her.  As a result, she was basically raised as an only child.

  • lastlyfirst@xanga

    I'm the youngest of six children (I have five older brothers.) While I am not entirely what the description depicts, I do have my moments of being self-centered and sensitive. I do tend to like to work alone and I am a hard-worker. However, I have never been described as being immature, even as a child. I've heard the 'spoiled' thing one time or two, from jealous older brothers who complained that they never got a TV in their bedroom when they were such & such age.


    I do think it's really interesting to see people fit a certain type just based on birth order though.

  • EccentricSiren@xanga

    I don't fit the firstborn profile at all. I am a musician, I don't like rules, and I like to be creative. I'm not particularly aggressive, but I'm not compliant either, unless I think the argument is going to go on forever and somene has to give in. I resent it that it's often me. I'm not a perfectionist at all, except with my music. I think I do have the dethronement fear, though. My younger brother has a very dominant personality. He is a lot better in social situations than I am. He knows how to get his way and still have everyone like him. I don't particularly like living in his shadow.


    I was talking to a friend about my youngest sister and me. He told me she seemed more like a firstborn than I did. Except she's not really the leader type. Neither am I. The only "leader" type in our family is my brother, who's the middle child and the only boy.

  • BugCatcher

    I would have to say I'm both a compliant and an aggressive firstborn...I'm nurturing and crave approval but at the same time i make lists detailing everything down to the minute.

  • filtered_sunlight@xanga

    As an only child, I suppose I got a bit of each of those... I like doing what I can to please people and approval is nice, but I can be a perfectionist in some areas of life. Flexible. Some would referr to my usual "need-to-know-basis" policy as secretive. I can be incredibly sensative. And I've been called "spoiled", though I'm quite sure that's what I would call it... [I do not have everything that I want nor do I expect people to just hand it to me, but I'm confident that I can, eventually get it.] Perhaps some of the others fit, too...but it can be hard to look that closely in the mirror, you know?


    At 7 weeks, Megan's really too young to tell where she's going personality-wise. She's been very easy going thus far.


    I've dated two men that were the babies of their families and found them to be the typical youngest child...very clingy and attention-seeking. If the pats on the head stopped, it seemed like their world fell apart and they couldn't deal with life. If things weren't going how they wanted them to, they became very moody. After the second one, I learned that asking about their birth order on the first date could give valuable insight on how the rest of the relationship would go.


    Tim is the first other only child that I've dated. We are a lot a like...which is both good and annoying at times. But the redeeming quality there is that we're both able to work alone on things; I've actually found that the youngest children want someone there and holding their hands whenever they're doing something. "Clean the kitchen? Only if you're there helping me!" It always started out sort of "cute", but got old quickly.

  • mayanao@xanga

    I'm the youngest and can relate to a lot with what is said on that list.

  • Leaving_a_Paperless_Trail@xanga

    Watching my own kids, and looking at my sibs and myself, I can say that IN GENERAL the birth order-personality link is true.  But people have a lot of factors that shape them, and birth order is only one.  I do some things that are very out of character for my birth order, but other things are spot-on.

  • jusanobody@xanga

    first born here. most defiant and most out-spoken, but totally got parts of both the passive & aggressive first born.

  • xthehalcyonx@xanga

    weird. i'm a first-born and i have the same personality as you do

  • emodoodle@xanga

    I'm a first born and I fit what you've said.

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • Post a Comment

  • Say it with Minis! (?)

  • Profile Pic

    Default | Choose » (?)
  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About this Entry

Who recommended?