Thursday, 11 September 2008

  • Morning Chat: Co-sleeping with Your Baby

    by Momaroo Team

    cosleeping

    Co-sleeping is the practice of sharing your bed with your babies or toddlers, instead of giving them their own cribs or beds. There are arguments both for and against co-sleeping.

    Proponents hold that co-sleeping saves babies' lives (especially in conjunction with nursing), promotes bonding, lets the parents get more sleep, facilitates breastfeeding, and protects against sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Older babies can breastfeed during the night without waking their mother.

    Opponents argue that co-sleeping is both stressful and dangerous for a baby, pointing to evidence that co-sleeping may increase the risk of SIDS. They also cite concerns that a parent may smother the child or promote an unhealthy dependence of the child on the parent(s). In addition, they contend that this practice may interfere with the parents' own relationship, by reducing both communication and sexual intercourse at bedtime, and argue that modern-day bedding is not safe for co-sleeping. [Source: Wikipedia]

    Do/did you co-sleep with your babies and/or toddlers, and if so, until what age? Whether you co-sleep or not, what factors helped you reach your decision?

Comments (35)

  • Amyld@xanga

    We do.  My youngest (17 months) sleeps with us every night.  The older girls moved out (on their own!) around the ages of 4.  It is not stressful, we have never had any type of accidents (no one has been hurt), and my sex life is very much active and well.  I just did what I felt was the natural and normal thing to do.  I could never imagine forcing a newborn to sleep in a crib, alone.

  • tequila_sky@xanga

    I  do and I did. Till the age of two/three. Um, I just figure that I am right next to my baby and that she is safer with me. I always felt that if I was in the ''wild'' I would definitely be sleeping with them and not leaving them in another ''cave''. I  have no idea, it just sort of developed like that, it felt more natural. 

  • willow_ann209@xanga

    My mom never co-slept with me. She liked her space, she told me later. We have a fine relationship, and she said she thinks it made me more independent because I didn't wake her at night, and as I grew up I learned to do things for myself faster than her friends kids did(like potty training, and dressing myself, and making my own food).

    I don't think I'll co-sleep with my baby, because I sleep like a rock, and I'd be scared of hurting my baby.

  • LifeGoals@xanga

    When we actually do have children I might think it seems natural and great, but right now I feel like I'd be too afraid of rolling onto my newborn while they sleep or that they'd get suffocated somehow in our bedding. lol we have enough problems with our little dog sleeping on our bed cause I move around too much!

  • runaheadofme@xanga

    We have successfully reduced both communication and sexual intercourse in order to make room for co-sleeping, of which the mother of my children is a stolid proponent. My two year old son is a light sleeper (like myself) and sleeps better when given his own space. Whenever his mother attempts to co-sleep with him he fusses and flops about and wakes up about five times a night. On the other hand, if he is given a consistent bedtime routine and put to sleep separately from us (but nearby) then he successfully sleeps through the night. My seven year old daughter has always slept like a rock and would still prefer to co-sleep. She resisted the transition to a toddler bed until she was five. She still climbs into bed with her mother every morning.

    I think the success of co-sleeping depends entirely on one's sleeping style and sensitivity to stimuli during the night. The deep sleepers in my family also prefer a plethora of night lights. My son and I tend to wake up too often if a night light is present in the room.

    I also wold posit that co-sleeping may promote an unhealthy dependence of the parent on the child, perhaps even to the point that they try to force co-sleeping on an unwilling participant.

  • cjamos@xanga

    I coslept with my kids until they were 4 months and then we slowly moved them out mostly so I could sleep beter and my yongest slept beter after moving her to a cradle in my room.  It worked well but I am now glad to have my own space and my own bed time.

  • averyswife@xanga

    We co-slept with our daughter, but not intentionally at first.  We had a bassinet, but soon found it easier and much more conducive to a good night sleep when she slept with us.  I didn't have to get out of bed to nurse her, plus I'm a very light sleeper so I was never worried about rolling on top of her.  She started sleeping through the night at around 6 weeks old.  At that point we tried moving her to her crib, but she would wake often, so we gave up.  Around 4 months old we gradually started weaning her to her crib and it worked beautifully and she sleeps like a log there now (13+ hours a night!).  We'll probably do that again with our next one just because we had such success with it.  It didn't interfere with mine and my husband's relationship at all either, so I would recommend it for the first few months of life if the baby is having a hard time sleeping on its own.

  • firetyger@xanga

    My daughter co-slept with us until she was about six months old.  I breastfed her and it was just easier for me to have her right next to me.  I was afraid at first that I might roll onto her since I've been a hard sleeper forever.  But once she was born, it was like my "mommy alert" was turned on.  To this day, the slightest sound wakes me at night.  In many ways I miss not having her next to me because I actually woke up less often back then.  The reason I moved her to a crib was because my husband wanted to be able to do things at night without having to worry about her, when he was home on leave.  He deployed when she was three months old, so in my mind it was completely understandable.  If circumstances had been different, I would have let her stay next to me until she was weaned off of breast milk. 

    As far as whether or not it affected her dependence on us...I have to say that I think she has a perfect balance.  She still loves to cuddle and snuggle at times, but she also loves doing things for herself and being quite independent.

  • Amarisa@xanga

    My bed is too squishily comfortable to be safe for an infant, so bassinet it is.

  • XbabyK@xanga

    @runaheadofme@xanga - Maybe I'm reading you wrong, but it seems like you do not like co-sleeping, which is fine, while your wife does.  It really should be something you both agree on, after all, you're sleeping in the bed too.  Perhaps you should discuss this with your wife and find a workable solution for all of  you.

  • XbabyK@xanga

    My baby just plain sleeps better with us, which means hubby and I both end up sleeping better.  In fact, once my daughter started sleeping with us, my hubby started thinking she was sleeping through the night because he never noticed her waking up to nurse.

  • mamajoyjoy

    We semi-co-sleep. Sometimes M will just not get back into her crib after awakening at night. Once her body is on our bed, she's usually out super fast. If I have the energy and am still awake to bring her back to her crib, I usually do.

  • KechiNeko244@xanga

    I don't think I'll co-sleep with my children, but my husband, if our child is a crier, will probably become desparate and put the baby in bed with us. I know this because he did it when we got a puppy! The puppy would not sleep on her pad and she cried all night. We put her in bed with us, and now she sleeps soundly.


    I'm not an advocate of co-sleeping. I think children should learn some independence, even when they're little. Besides, I have enough problems with a snuggly husband and a snuggly dog in bed; add a baby to the equation and I'll probably never get any sleep!

  • TashaDW_18@xanga

    We don't and won't co-sleep.  Not because I have anything against it - it's great for those who are breastfeeding and like having their babies in bed with them.  But I am unable to breastfeed so I have to get up to get a bottle anyway.  And I'm a VERY light sleeper and having a little one in bed with me keeps me up all night long.

  • Punk_Rock_Mommy@xanga

    We co-sleep.  Not sure how it evolved but it's been an awful experience.  I sleep horribly. When they were little, I was always afraid of rolling over on them.  And, now that they move around ALOT, I can't seem to sleep through the night.  We will not be co-sleeping with the new baby.  It's put a whole lot of stress on our marriage. It it works for you, great.  It has supplied a basic need for sleep and breastfeeding.  Besides that, I'm tired and I don't think that's been real great for me.  The one thing that has always stressed me out is the fear that I could smother one of my kids in the middle of the night.  My brother is a detective.  He has investigated many, many cases involving infant death and co-sleeping.  He begged me not to co-sleep--I don't discuss it with him!

  • Angel95Annie@xanga

    What a great topic! I've enjoyed reading the responses.  My mother didn't co-sleep with any her 5 children, but when I brought Lizzie home, I couldn't sleep without her in bed with me. I kept getting up to check on her, plus she couldn't sleep in the pack and play either.  As soon as I put her in it, (from day 1) she would squirm and cry, but once in our bed she was sleeping 3 or 4 hours straight at 1 month old! 

    My husband loves co-sleeping and is really looking forward to a "family bed" if Lizzie doesn't get fully weaned to her own bed before baby 2 gets here in April.  He loves rolling over and waking up to Lizzie patting his back and giggling in the morning.  We are getting a king size bed to accommodate 4 sleepers.

    I was never scared of rolling over on Lizzie. I agree with a previous poster - I was once a heavy sleeper, but once Lizzie was put in bed with us my "mommy alert" came on full force and as soon as I heard a peep from her my eyes popped open! I got more sleep this way too - I don't ever remember hearing her cry during the night until she was 4 months old.

    As far as too much dependence - I can see how parents might fall prey to depending too much on the child, but I am excited about letting Lizzie decide when she is ready for her own bed. Isn't that one of the best benefits of being a mother - watching and rejoicing as your child grows and develops?  I will let her decide when to wean from the breast and when to sleep in her own room. I'll encourage any small signs I see and be excited to see her grow! 

    I really don't agree that is makes the child too dependent on the mom/dad.  I have lots of family/friends that co-sleep and thier children are the most independent things ever!  Lizzie is 15 months old and lets me know what she wants to do and will take off down our driveway towards the goats without looking back to me.  I believe that by meeting your child's needs the best you know how, your child will grow to be independent. For now, I love that Lizzie still needs me, even though I am also excited that she is growing closer to her dad and more independent of her need of me so much :)

  • Erika_Steele@xanga

    Yes.  breastfeeding.  If I used formula and had to get up anyway, he would have actually slept in his crib.

  • SeafoamMermaid22@xanga

    My daughter slept in her bassinet until 6 months, then her crib for a few months, then migrated to my bed, where she still sleeps, at 28 months. I love it though, I love spending the extra time with her and I love getting a good night's sleep knowing she's safe and sound right next to me. 

  • LadyLibellule@xanga

    I would never co-sleep.  I move around too much when I sleep, so it wouldn't be safe.  And I think if I tried not to move around, I wouldn't get much sleep myself.

    I don't know of anyone in my generation who co-slept with their parents.  We all seem to be okay.  It's today's kids I'm worried about.  I personally know of a few who rob their parents of sleep because they never learned to be independent and now can't get themselves to sleep on their own.

    I think it's probably better not to start; then you don't have to break the habit later.

  • star_76@xanga

    Hmmmm.... this subject always has a lot of aspects to it. I think it's like a lot of other things in parenting. You have to make the choice that is best for you, and not be critical of others who choose differently. I never wanted to co-sleep because I don't sleep well (because of mommy radar) when there are kiddos in our bed.


    However - 'somehow' several nights a week we'd wake up to a little body snuggled in between us. (sigh) Sometimes I endure it (and get no sleep) because I don't feel like getting up and putting them back to bed and other times I put them back to bed after they're asleep.


    Now they're at the point where they bring their pillow and lay down on the carpet outside our bedroom door. I'm soooo okay with that. It only happens once a week at the most with our youngest and now almost never with our oldest....

  • AbsolutelyNormalChaos61308@xanga

    I didn't co-sleep with my daughter. And I don't plan on co-sleeping with baby #2 (who's due in April), either. I had my daughter in a bassinette (sp). She was right next to my bed, but in her OWN bed. So breastfeeding was easy. She was right next to me. I could hear her. But she was used to sleeping in her own bed. Which made the transition to her own room VERY easy.

  • scoopsofpoops@xanga

    I honestly think co-sleeping or not co-sleeping is a cultural thing.  The world seems to more increasingly and increasingly westernized, so to that - its more accepted not to co-sleep (and yes we have research and studies that say co-sleeping is not cool).  I co-slept with 3 out of my four children.  My 2nd child just wouldn't sleep without me, and I was in school studying, and it was just easier for him to sleep in bed w/ me while I studied, I am a single mother so unfortunately I did not have the help of the father with me.  My last two children, we did not have enough money to buy a crib or a bassinet, so there was no choice but to co-sleep.  I know so many people though from so many countries, and many for non-western countries have to co-sleep.  It was the norm where they were from.  But I guess where we live in America its not the thing to do I guess.  But to each his own, and everyone should carefully consider all options, and discuss with their partners and assess from their child's need whats best.  I'm definitely not against co-sleeping though, my kids turned out fine.  

  • Xyour_bloody_valentineX@xanga

    I would be afraid to co-sleep with my baby.  A woman I worked with almost smuther her baby that way.  She rolled over in the middle of the night.  My husband co-sleeps with his daughter when we have her but I do not plan to do so with ours [due in April].  She now refuses to sleep unless someone is in there.  Including when she is taking a nap.  And its a little frustrating for me sometimes.  I don't mind sleeping with her but she is definitely a kicker in her sleep and wakes me or him up constantly.  And between waking up to pee constantly and get comfortable [this is my first pregnancy and sleep has not been coming easy and I'll be 11 weeks on Saturday], waking up to being kicked or pushed just adds on to more uncomfortableness.  My mother raised four children [the youngest currently 9] and she didn't do it with any of us and I think it is better that way.  She can be independent but its alot harder because sometimes she won't.  Like she insist on being carried all the time and soon there will be another baby.  Plus, I can't carry her anymore since finding out I'm pregnant [doctor's orders] because she is too heavy.  As far as our future child. I would be much too scared to sleep with the baby in bed with me.  Because I roll around alot in my sleep and so does my husband.  However, there will be a crib right next to the bed in our room.  I think it would be easier just to have them in their own beds and own rooms once they get older.  It promotes independence which I think is very important to learn at a young age.  But that is simply my opinion.

  • incoherent__ramblings@xanga

    Absolutely not. My child has her own bed, in her own room. She has slept in it since the first night home from the hospital.

  • nicolevw@xanga

    I think it's definitely a matter of choice, for each family's situation is different.  But I also think that there is a lot of misconception and misunderstanding out there about the safety and benefits of co-sleeping.


    We slept with our youngest when it became a sanity issue for me.  I wasn't getting much sleep at all what with breastfeeding through the night, and not having the opportunity to nap during the day because of 3 other children forced me to co-sleep to get sleep!  And I LOVED it,  My hubby wasn't bothered by it and we found other creative ways to keep our marriage alive and well.   He would nap in his own bed during the day, start out the night in his own bed, and then when he woke up for his first feeding, I'd take him to bed with me.    He gradually outgrew it and now at age 4 is a super independent very well adjusted boy.   His older siblings, I'd say, are actually less independent to a certain extent, and I often wonder if the way we parented them with sleep issues affected that .......things like forcing them to sleep alone and crying themselves to sleep.


    Since having my last baby I've done alot of research on co-sleeping.  I HAVE heard that mothers can smother their babies ....but there has usually been a reason for that ...medication/drugs/alcohol/smoking/mental issues etc.   Yes, there have been babies who died because of suffocation - but in many cases it was because of bedding and spaces between mattress and headboard or what have you.  There are definitely safe ways to co-sleep and I'll bet that many of the babies who died while cosleeping was because of unsafe practices.


    The fact of the matter is that human infants are DESIGNED to be with mother.   We are mammalian, and ALL mammals keep their babies close to them 24/7.  Out of all the cultures of the world, the western culture is the only one that insists that our immature infants learn to be "independent" from birth by forcing them to sleep alone in a separate room and in a crib all by themselves.   Our human babies are designed to be kept close to mom so that she can learn her baby's rhythms and needs.  So she can respond to the baby's hunger cues and other cues.  Babies that stay with mom have better temperature regulation, have lower stress hormones, cry less and are generally happier babies. In many other cultures babies are attached to their mothers (known as baby-wearing) and co-sleep.  They are fine.  SIDS? not heard of there.   SIDS often happens precisely because WE ARE NOT THERE.   SIDS does not occur when babies sleep next to mom because our sleep cycles become very close, and neither babe nor mom enters the deep sleep cycle.  (you should google Dr. James McKenna who has done numerous studies in his sleep lab on this very issue). 


    You may also want to check out Dr. Harvey Karp - author of Happiest Baby on the Block for his information on what babies need - and how we can deliver it so that we don't have colicky fussy babies, but well contented happy babies.


    All this said, I recognize that there are many parents out there who are just not comfortable with the idea of sleeping with their babies- and that's okay.  All I'd ask is that those parents do read up on it and understand the safety and benefits of co-sleeping so that it is better understood.  If after that, they still want separate sleeping quarters - then all the more power to them!  Whatever works to make a happy family I say!


    Thanks for reading my awfully long comment!! 

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.