Tuesday, 12 August 2008

  • Potty Training Success!

    MamaButterflyby Mama Butterfly

    I think it's safe to say that it's official. My 2 1/2 year-old son is potty trained! I suppose he has been for a few weeks, but I was waiting for that dreaded "regression" that so many people have told me about. I thought I'd share my strategy, in case it helps anyone else!

    I have to start out by saying that I absolutely dreaded this task. I had heard horror stories and had been privy to some of them in my own extended family. I had heard that boys are harder to train than girls, and are more prone to bed wetting, etc. From the day I found out I was pregnant, I always thought of potty training as the crown of motherhood, and if you can teach a child to go on the potty, you can do anything! Thankfully, I will say up front that it wasn't nearly as bad or difficult as I thought it would be. 

    We introduced the potty when he was very young. We had a little potty sitting in the bathroom since he was less than a year old, and he was able to sit on it whenever he wanted. We would always sit him on it before bath time, so it wasn't a new thing when we really "dug our heals in." We waited until a week when we didn't have any plans and wouldn't have to leave the house very often. On Monday morning, he woke up, and I told him that his diapers were all gone, so he would have to start using the potty when he had to go. I don't know if he totally grasped what I was saying, but he seemed to get the general idea. I laid towels down on our couch, and left him naked on the bottom half all day (much to his excitement - what is it with males and being naked?). I reminded him to sit on the potty about every 20 minutes or so, and kept really pushing the liquids so that he would have lots of practice. Every time he successfully went, he was able to choose a piece of candy. We used small items so that he didn't have a sugar overload  (i.e. M&M's, Smarties, mini-tootsie rolls, etc). The first day he only had 3 accidents, and the second and third days he only had 2. After the first 4 days or so, he started wearing underwear when we were home and pull-ups when we were out. It also became to be so normal that he just naturally stopped asking for the candy - we didn't offer it and would honor it if he asked, but eventually he just forgot about it. Even if he wouldn't have, I would not have had an issue with just telling him that we weren't going to get candy any more. Once it became habit, I don't think he would have regressed. The only regression we experienced was in the "poopy" arena. About 2 weeks after he was trained, he randomly started going in his underwear. We just let him go naked again and that solved it in about 1 day, because he realized if he didn't have any where to go, he had to go on the potty.

    To sum it up, we found that rewarding the potty training worked well. We tend to be a little more on the strict/discipline side of things, but positive reinforcement seemed to work so much better in this arena. It wasn't nearly as bad as I thought, and although I know all kids are different, and this is only my first, I was proud of how quickly he picked it up. It's been almost 2 months now and he hasn't had any accidents in about a month. He doesn't wear a pull-up at night and I'm so proud of him! I thought I'd summarize some of the main things that we found helpful:

    • Positive reinforcement seemed to be really key
    • Introduce the potty early, so it becomes something normal. I think a lot of kids balk because it seems so foreign.
    • Boys (and kids in general) tend to be visual. Allowing him to be naked made him quickly see when he had an accident. It also made him more aware of himself and how his body works.
    • We realized that part of the "poopy" regression was due to him not wanting to take the time away from playing to go. We did end up disciplining him a few times for not going to the potty, because we realized it was a choice he was making, not a true accident. It's helpful to realize the difference!
    • He really wanted to be like Daddy. I've heard that boys tend to be potty trained faster when there daddies are involved because it's helpful for them to be able to relate. It's a good excuse to have Dad be a help, if it's an option!
    • Be patient and realize that they're learning something new! If your child doesn't pick it up right away, give it a rest and try again a few weeks later (this successful attempt was attempt #2 - we had tried about 2 months prior, and we all ended up frustrated, but another month or so really made a difference for him).

    Good luck!

    What age did you start potty training your child? What potty training tips worked for you?

Comments (15)

  • goodluckduck@xanga

    I need to remember these tips for when I have children!

  • glorious_and_free@xanga

    We are in the midst of doing basically the same as you.  Only we use stickers.  Our daughter is 2.5 and has been really stubborn with not wanting to go in the potty.  But we're finally pushing it harder and just not allowing diapers besides at night.  It's been frustrating because she's known how to use the potty for a while, but she just doesn't want to.  We still have issues sometimes when she wears underwear.  If she's naked she'll use the potty just fine, but if she has underwear on she will just go in them, take them off, and keep playing.  Although out of nowhere yesterday and today she has actually managed to stop what she's doing, take off her pants and underwear, and use the potty a couple times.  So we're keeping our fingers crossed.

  • shearoc@xanga
  • Zvanoizu@xanga

    Congrats and GREAT tips! My girls are ten and nearly eight. I thought it would take forever to get them potty-trained. LOL. But they are.


    I kind of crumpled when I realized we still had shoe ties to teach. LOL. We got there too.

  • TashaDW_18@xanga

    My son turned 3 in June and he has just become completely potty-trained in the last month or so (except at night...he still wets his pull-ups alot at night....).


    My strategy was about the same as yours, candy, not letting him wear diapers, etc.  Once he was ready, he got the hang of it really fast and it wasn't nearly the horrible ordeal I've always heard about.

  • mamamonkey

    YEAH!!! I am starting to think about it with my son who will be 2 in early Sept. He has started showing interest in the potty (though he hasn't gone on it yet) and has been waking semi-regularily with dry diapers and going right after he gets up. So I think I will start with sitting him on the potty first thing in the morning and see how it goes. Hope he continues to do well for you.

  • goodgirl_196@xanga

    Congrats on the potty training!

  • jaywalkers@xanga

    oh you lucky lucky moms. my son is 3 and a half and still really struggles with poo. also, he doesn't ever sleep through the night dry. i did just about the same method that you did, but it took him a loooooot longer. we've been working on this hard core (after trying it five times before) for seven months now and poop is the issue that he can't let go (literally and figuratively, heh heh).

  • jaywalkers@xanga

    just in case you're inclined to judge i will also mention that my just-turned-two year old is nearly potty-trained. let's give it up for the girls. :)

  • sexy_crzy_grl@xanga

    Thanks for sharing....  we are workign on potty training now and have been on and off for a long time.  My son will turn 3 in November.  I think night wetting will be a huge issue for us too.  He always wakes up with a soaked pull up (so bad I have to use the good nights...  he's tall for his age).

  • Jackie_Pearl@xanga

    My daughter started her potty traning at 18 months. By the time she turned 2 last month, she can go to the restroom alone and pee or poo. Although she still loves to yell at me, just to show me she can now  use the potty.

  • nikkidreamer@xanga

    i have a stubborn 3 yr old girl who will pee on the potty only when i take her (she never choses to go or tells me she needs to go to the potty) and will not poop on the potty. not for money, candy, sugared drinks, new toys, special movie privileges- not even for all of the above all at once. there is nothing that will convince her to use the potty for poop. i am worried that she will be 4 or even 5 before she decides she feels like using the potty. it does not matter how many of her friends and family use the potty. she has no interest in impressing anyone with doing an adult thing. it's very difficult when the 2 and 3 yr olds all around us are training, and I wonder if her little brother will train before she ever does. she doesn't care about feeling wet and when I try leaving her bottoms off, she doesn't care if she poops and wets around the house. she is embarrassed by nothing. there is always the wait and try again later advice. this is the 4th time I've tried. its real funny everyone who wants to laugh and say "they won't go to college in diapers so don't worry" i'm not worried about college, i'm tired of wiping up the poop right now.

  • Andrea_TheNerd@xanga

    No way would I leave my son without diapers.  He climbs up on everything constantly.  Last thing I need is a urine-soaked computer.

  • aliandrajade@xanga

    Both of my girls refused to be potty trained.  I started with my first at 2.5 and she would pee on the potty like a pro but after the first poo in the potty she completely freaked then wouldn't get on the potty again til she was 3.5.  Both of my girls don't care about accidents or having to clean up the mess (I would have them help) one day they just decided to do it...quite stubborn my girls!  With my second she was even more uninterested in the potty and would rather pee on herself while playing than even acknowledge the need to go.  We told her if she would start going potty she could start ballet, didn't care!  When she decided to go she did and within a month she was potty trained pretty much by herself. 

    My son just turned two and he is pulling off his diaper and knocking on the bathroom door all the time.  It driving us nuts!  He tries all the time but really only goes in his diaper so we are buying a potty (something I swore I wouldn't do since my girls never used theirs) then he can practice without me having to drop everything and running to the bathroom.  Wish me luck hopefully he will be trained soon?!

  • NotUeberMommy

    @Andrea_TheNerd@xanga - haha... that was funny. But seriously, I'm a little worried about my newly covered hand-me-down designer couch... eeek.


    My son is 16 months old, and that's about the normal age to start potty training in Holland (and other European countries, I think!). It's insane, if you ask me, but we'll buy a potty nevertheless. I'm thinking we'll make a big deal out of it; have him choose a potty in the store, that sort of thing. We'll see if it works.


    What really seems to help with all his developmental steps, is that my nephew is three months older - once he saw how fast his cousin could walk, he just up and went! So I'm thinking he'll need a little nudge in this area, too.

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About this Entry

Who recommended?