Wednesday, 30 July 2008
-
Let's Give Our Teens Contraceptives... With or Without Parental Consent
by Nurse Jenna
As many of you may have read about or heard of the news, the group of 17 high school girls in Gloucester, Massachusetts who made the “Pregnancy Pact” have, or are giving birth this summer. Apparently these girls all decided together that it seemed like a good idea to have a baby and purposefully set out to get pregnant. Though one can only speculate upon what goes through the adolescent mind, what I find even more appalling is what goes through the adult minds that are supposed to be helping and guiding these young girls.
While many parents feel their daughters (and sons) should not be allowed access to birth control without their consent, what they fail to realize by this logic it that their children will still have sex without their consent. Because of these consent issues, the girls of Glouster High (and I’m sure the same goes for schools across the nation) are not allowed to obtain contraceptives from the school health center. Ironically, they are, however, allowed to take pregnancy tests at the school without their parents’ knowledge.
This might be a moot point with this particular group of girls since they were on a mission to get a pregnant, but I work with many teens every day who certainly were not hoping to end up pregnant. While there is always the popular argument for abstinence, we know how far that goes…about as far as you can throw a baby crib.
So why can’t we just accept that our teens ARE going to have sex and why can’t we provide them with the proper protection with or without their parents’ permission?
Post a Comment
- Back to momaroo's Momaroo Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in momaroo's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)















Comments (219)
Why? Because there is a stupid law that says so.
For a freshman collegiate writing assignment, I chose to write about the Abstinence-Only program. It was a required 3 page paper (intro writing class, obviously), and after my factual research and being able to minimally express my own opinion, it ended up being 7 when I decided I should wrap it up. For a freshman government assignment, we had to write to our state senator addressing a public issue--I forwarded my paper.
This is a real issue in this country and while abstinence-only is great (I happen to follow it) it has so many flaws, is damaging to some, and is counter active to others.. Obviously I could rant on and on about this, but I'm going to choose not to.
I just hope that is one law that gets changed, and SOON.
@BABY_LETSGETTHIN@xanga - Just because you have been dating this boy for seven months doesn't mean that you are ready to have sex with him. Sex is an ADULT activity and at fourteen years old you are not an adult by any means.
Have you ever had a real job? Do you have a driver's license? Have you ever balanced a check book or payed a bill all by yourself?
Maybe these things don't sound related to sex, but they are. They are all indicative of the maturity and responsibility that is necessary to truly deal with the possible consequences of sex. Of course sexual desire can happen when you're fourteen, but that doesn't mean that you are old enough to act on it. I would earnestly encourage you to wait. You aren't even of a legal age to consent to sex, and there is a reason for that.
Has anybody else thought of this? We are supposed to be handing out contraceptives to children who aren't even legal to have sex? It's really disgusting. Not to mention, there are already ways for teenagers who choose to have sex to be safe (i.e. go to the pharmacy and by your own protection). There's no reason for SCHOOLS to be giving them FREE contraceptives. I can't even get free condoms as a 22 year old woman but we want to give them to our children?
I'm sorry, but I think parents should have some say in putting their underage teens on birth control. I can't believe our society has gotten to the point where we can even ask this question.
Sometimes, I eat popcorn.
But usually, I don't.
)D.B. Platypus(
THANK YOU.
In this generation, sex is EVERYWHERE. Television, music, movies, magazines; you name it, and unfortunately, all of those things play a huge role in a teenager's life. They will be influenced by what they see and hear, making it damn-near impossible to be a virgin in the 21st century. If you're going to be sexually active, and you don't want babies, you must be on birth control! Can't we all at least agree that that's better than another unplanned baby in the world?
I agree with everything you said.
I'm a teenager myself, however I know the difference between right and wrong, and its wrong for us to deny birth control to teens without parents consent. You are nothing but 100% correct. We know teens are stubborn, and many of us are going to do what we wanna do, so why not provide us with the protection we need?
Well said !
@xxmusicxxfreak@xanga - i totally agree with you. nicely put.
Hey Ladies, I am a father to 3 small girls the eldset is just turning 10 and my wife and I both are kinda shit scared on what might happen when our girls are older and err 'more active'. I happend to see this string on a very thoughtful topic hence here I am to react a bit and add to what's being said.
The idea of handing over contracePtives does seem nice but I think its kind of giving a tacit go ahead for sex....rather 'early sex'. As parents dont we know that there's a time and moment for virtually everything in our lives. We get our driving licences only when we attain a certain age, can vote only after we're old enough. Can go for dates 'after' a certain age, can come home late (!) 'after' a certain age. Taking a cue from this should we not try to inculcate THIS habit / practice in our children that there are certain times for certain things in our lives. That we should not unnecessarily fast forward our lives just cos we 'felt like having it'. There are things like awareness about sex and its complications, abstinence and the reasoning of it on which we ...not only parents but schools AND parents of the friends..should TALK to the young adults on.
I certainly abide by the point of the schools TAKING OVER the lives of OUR children and teaching them THEIR values. We actually refused admissions of our children to one popular day long school where in our opinion the school would have had more time with the children (considering the awake hours) than we parents would have had. The school thought it was a good idea to 'help' the parents..we booed the idea and came off. Our point was we're sending to school to SUPPLEMENT the kids to some knowledge and ways of live, not be as the main provider of information on ways of life.
So I feel its more of 'communicating' to the kids on whats the right ways of life and whats not so right. There would be exceptions in every ways of life. But then we dont set the rules for the vast majority governed by the few exceptions. Exceptions would have to be handled separately. Lets not colour every young adult with the same thought or expectation.
I am sorry if I have been a bit too much but its a very important topic and I was like..i went on..!! Thanks for reading through if you did!!
its all a part of growing up i figure, give younger folk means to protect themselves rather than just expecting them to wait. if they're gonna be responsible about it then they should get more freedom.
@bellydancegirl8@xanga -
"@mamahippo - I think you just said all of that because you were a slut that had premarital sex.
Keep your legs closed and teach your children to do the same. People like you shouldn't be having babies."
Excuse me? Are you fucking serious??
BTW @bellydancegirl8@xanga - I will teach my son that he should wait, but that if he chooses to have sex to be responsible and protected, both for his and his partner's sake. That is much more important to me than him waiting till he's married to have sex.
I will also teach him not to be a cocky asshole who makes such rude, ugly, and inappropriate comments to people that he knows absolutely nothing about and that make him look like an immature jackass.
lol if kids are going to be fucking retarted then let them get pregnant/get someone pregnant and learn the hard way. failing to use protection can ruin the rest of your life. when i have kids, i will give them birth control/condoms.....but only if they are strong enough to ask.
and they will do it anyway.....weather you want them to or tell them not to....most teens will do it. i'm gonna leave it up to them to tell me and be strong enough to ask for condoms or birth control. might as well be safe....
I must disagree with the statement that abstinence doesn't work, or doesn't happen. It most certainly does. Of course, not as often as it should. But are we surprised when sex is everywhere from TV, movies, magazines, everything! And then expect them NOT to have sex? Come on!
Really, I just wanted to say that I think more teens DO practice abstinence than we realize. I for one, was one of them.
Kids pushing the envelope!!!
Cant say I was surprised.
You can't trust parents to make wise decisions about their TEENAGERS' lives. There are still parents out there who would be so outraged that their "little girl" is doing "slut things" that they would literally throw out the pills! (Seen it!)
These are the same parents who would force a teenager to carry a pregnancy to term, or disown them if they were pregnant!
The whole consent thing is for caring, understanding, educated parents. Not typical ones.
@MyPrecious@xanga - Blaming the media doesn't help -- both sex and violence are facts of life, and people need to be exposed to them. However, children do need some guidance toward unbiased sources in order to make an informed, educated decision.
If the students are over the age of consent, then refusing birth control is just ridiculous. If the law says they're old enough to have sex, then they're old enough to make decisions about being protected. If they're UNDER the age of consent, however, we have a completely different problem on our hands.
Still, our bodies mature and move us toward the idea of sex at a societally "early" age. While these girls may not really be mature enough to have children and raise them, and may be too young for hormonal contraceptives to be advisable (mostly due to side effects and whatnot), they should at least be offered condoms. Last I checked (aside from latex allergies, and there's always silicone!), condoms don't have any side effects.
I agree completely. While I'm not sexually active, a very close friend of mine is. Her parents views on sex are very conservative, and she couldn't talk to them about sex or birth control. When she became sexually active, she mentioned to me that her boyfriend was too embarrassed to buy condoms. (In my opinion, if you're not mature enough to buy condoms, you're not mature enough to have sex.) He was getting them from gas station bathroom machines. I'm glad they were using some form of protection, but still, it wasn't the most reliable. The question parents should ask themselves is, 'Do we want our teens chancing pregnancy and STDs behind our backs, or do we want them to be protected and having safe sex behind our backs?' Why should it matter where teens get protection, as long as they use it?
As a teenager I feel I can give a unique view to this topic. First, I'll admit I'm not an angel, and I have had sex but my knowledge does not only come from personal experience but also my peers. Secondly, I would like to say that I have gotten involved with this topic on the community level. I have joined a group sponsored by the local red cross called peer educators. I travel to the middle schools and highschools in the community giving presentations about the prevention of AIDS and thus - in extention- condoms.
Many of the comments I have read on this topic have the same theory going on. Many assume that if you talk to your kids about staying abstinent they are going to listen. Yes, I agree. This is a good thing to teach. Also, getting involved in your children's lives is a good thing as well. But, the truth is, teenagers do make their own decisions, whether stupid ( and many of them are ) or not. If they want to have sex they will. And they WILL find away around all the precautions you have set.
So this aside, do you want them to be safe? Many children do not want to tell their parents that they are sexually active. If they aren't going to, do you want them to have the opportunity to protect themselves? Yes, I understand that keeping the birth control situation non-confidential it tries to keep children from keeping it a secret from you. But it wont. They will do it anyway. And I'm sure you all want your childrent to be safe.
( " but my kid isn't like that". right? Even the smartest, most involved, most sincere child would suprise you. you should hear the things I hear on a daily basis.)
These are all excellent points. I am 21 years old, and lost my virgnity when I was 15. I was recently a teenager and can tell you that I didn't have the courage to talk to my parents about sex. I learned about sex at a young age without school or parents. Mostly media and friends. When I learned about sex, I also knew about different types of birth control. I always used condoms with my boyfriend at the time. (And yes they are very readily available to anyone who wants to buy them). So I never got pregnant, but I was not mature or responsible enough to make those decisions on my own. When I am a parent I am going to push talking about sex with my children so they are comfortable with it, and it is not a secret. But teaching abstinance is great. For religious purposes, but more importantly moral issues.
I agree with whoever said "Kids will do it anyway" is a excuse for adults who can't control their children. Kids and teens are constantly trying to find their boundaries and experiment with what they can and can not do. If you leave a cookie out, you know your child will take it. But if you don't tell the child why it is wrong to take the cookie, then they don't understand and will do it anyway.
Oral contraceptives are quite dangerous and have had my own bad experiences with it. My sister got birth control from a planned parenthood center, because she knew she was going to be sexually active with her boyfriend. Well, she ended up getting blood clots, and other serious medical problems from the birth control. The medical bills are very high because my parents didn't have insurance, and we are lucky to have my sister today. So I absolutely do not agree that teens should be able to get oral birth control with out their parents consent because it is a medical issue. Condoms are readily available and if you choose to have sex at any age. And you are responsible for your birth control. You can get condoms at any gas station or grocery store, so there should be no more excuses.