Wednesday, 30 July 2008
-
Let's Give Our Teens Contraceptives... With or Without Parental Consent
by Nurse Jenna
As many of you may have read about or heard of the news, the group of 17 high school girls in Gloucester, Massachusetts who made the “Pregnancy Pact” have, or are giving birth this summer. Apparently these girls all decided together that it seemed like a good idea to have a baby and purposefully set out to get pregnant. Though one can only speculate upon what goes through the adolescent mind, what I find even more appalling is what goes through the adult minds that are supposed to be helping and guiding these young girls.
While many parents feel their daughters (and sons) should not be allowed access to birth control without their consent, what they fail to realize by this logic it that their children will still have sex without their consent. Because of these consent issues, the girls of Glouster High (and I’m sure the same goes for schools across the nation) are not allowed to obtain contraceptives from the school health center. Ironically, they are, however, allowed to take pregnancy tests at the school without their parents’ knowledge.
This might be a moot point with this particular group of girls since they were on a mission to get a pregnant, but I work with many teens every day who certainly were not hoping to end up pregnant. While there is always the popular argument for abstinence, we know how far that goes…about as far as you can throw a baby crib.
So why can’t we just accept that our teens ARE going to have sex and why can’t we provide them with the proper protection with or without their parents’ permission?
Post a Comment
- Back to momaroo's Momaroo Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in momaroo's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)













Comments (220)
You have a wonderful point. Teens are going to make the decision on whether or not to have sex on their own. Most will make the decision to have sex, so I believe that we should do our best to educate and protect them, whether parents consent or not. I really hope that when my daughter is that age she will feel comfortable enough to come to me, but if she's not I'd love for her to have a way to protect herself. I'd like to know but if she feels she can't come to me I want her to have somewhere to turn.
Abstinence-only education worked for me, along with being educated on the potential risks involved with sexual intercourse, especially at a young age: STDs, emotional scarring, pregnancy, et cetera.
I'm with you on this one. I was the rare teen (it seemed like anyways) that didn't become sexually active until I was nearly a legal adult but pretty much most of the girls and guys I knew were active. One of my g/f's had even had an abortion at 14. It's reality that teens are going to have sex and really need the easy access to contraceptives and condoms to keep them from unwanted pregnancies or bad health consequences.
oh Nurse jenna you missed again one of the very big main points.....how involved were the parents in these girls lives?why are we letting ths schols totally raise our kids?now i'm not saying i stayed absitent till marriage cuz i didnt.But growing up and still to this day i have a very open talking relationship with my parents.i was educated on how they'd like me to wait till marriage and why i should but they also told me if i chose to have sex to come to them and they would get me on birth control and you know what they held up to their end of the bargain!
i just feel that a lot of parents these days are allowing other people to raise their kids.allowing other people to push their values onto THEIR kids.My parents talked to me and with me about every aspect of my life growing up i was made aware od std's early pregnancies and AIDS.I was also taught about the various forms of birth control and that the pulling out method was not a sure thing so please dont even try it.I was also talked to about me being adopted from the time i could understand it.When i needed help in school my parents didnt hire a tutor they talked to me.
While i can see your point of school's trying to help out kids by offering birth control i do not agree with it.we need to make a national movement to bring our kids back home where they belong for the parents to take responsibility for the kids they are raising.i know it's not feesible for every mother to stay home but that still doesnt mean you cant make efforts to talk with your kids and if you start it at an early age it wont seem awkward to them.if you're starting now while your kids is a bit older yes it will be awkward but as a parent your first job is to raise your children and to teach them and support them.
and i have another question for you ms jenna....i tried to pm it to you but i couldnt.are you yourself a parent?
I just wrote a paper about this very topic in my summer composition class. I believe that our teens need what is now referred to as abstinence-plus education, which means that our schools teach abstinence, but also give information about STDs and contraception.
As a parent, I am on the fence right now (my daughter is only 4 and I haven't given the topic much thought on a personal level). While I would like the schools to teach her about contraception, I don't think I would like them to give it to her without my knowledge.You make a great point, Nurse Jenna. Abstinence only education is a great concept, but it's just that a concept. Teens in today's society are having sex and the # of children born to women under the age of 18 speaks for that. The problem with abstitence only programs is that they only teach abstitence; the programs do not educate those who are going to choose or have already chose to have sex. By educating teens about sex - the risks, consequences, why you should/shouldn't, etc you are lowering the statistics on teen pregnancy, stds, abortions, etc. If is unfair to the youth today to not have access to birth control at school. If they can have sex without permission then they should have the ability to protect themself without permission. You can't even go into WalMart to buy condoms without being carded... it's ridiculous... I'm all for sex education and having birth control available to teens in schools as long as education accompanies it.
And one more point... to those who will then say that sex education is the responsibility of parents I totally agree. However, let's be honest - the majority of parents are too busy working and paying bills, barely scraping by to survive, to sit down and have 'the talk' with their child. And if 'the talk' is happening most children are comfortable enough with the topic to discuss it with their parents - they go to their friends. So let's educate these friends so the advice being given at least has some ounce of truth to it.
Ok sorry for a long comment... I'm off my soap box now :). ~Susan~
I was sexually active at 15, pregnant at 17. I remember exactly how scared I was to ask my mom about birth control. The one time I bought it up, skirting the issue by saying that my best friend's mom let her get BC my mom called her a slut.
That killed the conversation real fast. My boyfriend, now husband, and I just stuck with condoms (until we had a stupid moment...)
My husband and I agreed on teaching our boys from an early age (with age appropriate content of course) about relationships, sex, pregnancy and HIV/STDs. I want to keep open communication between us and let them know they can come to us if they need to. I want to know what is going on in all aspects of their life including their relationships. We will teach them how to respect their girlfriends and be safe if they do choose to become sexually active regardless if they wait until their are legally adults or not. (I know many ADULTS that have no clue about the different kinds of birth control out there.) We will keep condoms in the house, probably the bathroom, so they can get one if they need to.
While I don't really like the idea of my boys having sex as teenagers, I'm not naive enough to think they won't. I'm not going to rely on their friends or the school system (if they go since we are homeschoolers now) to teach my kids what parents are supposed to teach. It is the parents responsibility to keep our children safe. If we are too busy to have at least a 15 minute conversation about sex, we have bigger problems.
I totally agree.
I recently graduated and I know firsthand from the time I did spend in a large high school (I'm talking like 1500 kids), that a pretty good majority are sexually active.I think as a young adult, it would be easier and a million times less embarrassing to go to a teacher or some other mutual figure for contraception then to your own parents.
@javamommy@xanga - While I agree with you that a parent has the primary responsibility of raising their children and having open and honest communication with them, I feel that you aren't grasping the reality that a lot of teens face. Open honest communication with parents isn't always possible for teens for many reasons and we shouldn't assume that there is. Sadly I was one of them, but at my school they had a great sex education program that covered everything from abstinence to contraception to STDs. They need to have an avenue to speak with someone who can guide them in the right direction even when parents won't. I agree with Nurse Jenna on this one, teens will have sex with or without permission. The best that we can do is offer a place where professionals can offer treatment and advice should the teens not be able get help/advice from parents. Just my two cents.
While I feel that parents should at least be informed that their teens are obtaining BC, realistically I realize that this would keep some teens from getting it. Also I feel that parents should be more aware and more involved in their teens' lives so they should maybe have some inkling that their kids are having sex and should initiate a conversation with them about it. My daughter is still too young to worry about this but I hope to encourage her to feel comfortable enough with her father and me to talk to us about her feelings and decisions. I think that sex ed classes should emphasize abstinence more though, it seems they go with the attitude of you're going to do it anyway, but abstinence is the only 100% BC. It'd be better if they delved more into the emotional side of it and other reasons to abstain besides it being the most reliable BC.
@javamommy@xanga - I have not missed my own point....but I think you may have :) I would be very happy if people would educate their children at home and this would become a parent/child issue. However, the reality vs the fantasy needs to be separtated here. Even in the best, most functional households, sex is an uncomfortable topic for most people to have with their teenage children and teens to have with their parents. If it is addressed at home---great. If not, there needs to an additional resource for information and contraception to prevent unwanted teen pregnancy and STDs. I believe this should be given out to teens with or without their parents permission. If they could talk to their parents to get persmission for contraception, they probably already would have talked to them about the topic, right?
@SmilingSusie01@xanga - You make an excellent point and are absolutely right that we want our kids going to someone with reliable information as opposed to their friends when they are not going to their parents.
@TornadoChaser - Again, couldn't agree more with how you plan to handle it. Wish all parents were this responsible and realistic about things.
@rockerbaby215@xanga - Good to hear from someone who knows how it is.
being a teenager myself, i am very aware of how prevalent sexual activities (or the talk about it) go on around me. but that's where it stops. my parents neverrr spoke to me about sex or anything of the sort. still, i know i am not ready, nor do i want to be sexually active around this age.
my high school teaches us all about abstinence but also about certain contraceptives that we can take and where to get them. i don't believe that they distribute them at school though.
so to answer the question, i think my school (and most others around the u.s.) pretty much know that not everyone is going to abide by their abstinence suggestion, even with the lessons on stds, pregnancy, etc. which is why they inform us thoroughly about how to use protection and whatnot.
still. just accepting that teens are going to have sex is somewhat unimaginable (maybe unethical?). that's like giving them the heads up and being okay with it. i'd rather they still try to steer us in the right direction.
I just graduated from High School, so I had to deal with some of my classmates getting pregnant, friends worried about getting pregnant. It was ridiculous. I think schools should give out birth control or something cause you are right, kids ARE going to have sex without consent. It's sad, but true and we don't want them becoming irresponsible parents with a run away father or the mother still in school. Schools should start acting upon these things.
@agent_ann@xanga - This to me is an ethical decision that each person makes for themselves, I do not make it for them. What I do believe it is my responsibility to do is to "steer people in the right direction" in so much is that they take responsibility for their actions. From a healthcare perspective (which is my job), this means preventing communicable diseases and unwanted pregnancies. It is not my personal or professional position to tell them that it is right or wrong to have sex---that would depend on their personal values and beliefs and their emotional readiness. As long as there is no abuse involved, I am not there to decide who is "allowed." I don't think it is the same as "encouraging sex" to provide information and contraception. The sex is happening anyway. Again, from a healthcare perspective, we want to see this become "safe sex."
@la_vida_linda@xanga - and to nurse Jenna..... so we just let the parents off scott free?i am not out of touch trust me....i do totally understand all the things teenagers face.i guess my point to this is so we have the schools step up and start handing out contraceptives instead of equip the parents with the right tools?i have 2 stepsons who have been raised to be afraid to talk to their parents about anything i've spent the last year deprogramming this from them and they are finally at a place where they can come to me to talk to me about things.I went to a highschool where teen pregnancy was prevelant.I also took in a niece when i was adult who was addicted to drugs to help her get clean (i had been their myself) and she ended up being 5 months pregnant when she came to live with us.the one thing she was scared to death of was telling her mom.so MY point is why as parents are we doing this to our kids?i do not try to be my kids friends i am their parent and this is part of a parents responsibilities not the schools.Nurse Jenna you didnt answer my question are you yourself a parent?
@javamommy@xanga - I didn't say let the parents off scott free, but the problems we are facing today cannot be fixed over night, or heck even in one generation. I was lucky, my older brother was out of medical school by the time I got into high school, but most kids aren't that lucky. There isn't enough big brothers and good aunts to reach every kid when they are in trouble. We need to understand that and take action accordingly.
@agent_ann@xanga - a right direction is a funny thing...I think parents and teens should decide what the right thing is. Schools shouldn't teach about right and wrong where sex is concerned, however I do feel that they should present the facts about abstinence, BC, and STDs so that teens can make an informed decision, especially for those teens who aren't getting the information from their parents.
@la_vida_linda@xanga - or we need to start with ourselves...i know it cant be freely fixed over night.but what can we do with OUR own kids to help.i would love to see some statistics too(please dont think i'm being sarcastic cuz i'm not i'm wondering)of how high teen pregnancy rates were when teens had to go to planned parenting and get birth control with a parent to what they are now even when we hand out contraceptives freely.
also a good point nurse jenna brought up(see i dont tottaly disagree with her) is those girls that got pregnant at the highschool had made a pact to get pregnant.so like she pointed out the contraceptives at school wouldnt have helped.thats where i asked where were the parents in this time?
i dont think handing out free contraceptives without parent permission is a good idea regardless.plus if the kid is not even matur enough to say mom i'm having sex shes not mature enough to have sex in my opinion.and yes my two stepsons mom was a teen when she got pregnant why???because she was afraid to talk to her own mom.so instead of covering up the problem with a blanket lets get to the root of it
@javamommy@xanga - I agree which is why I have a plan on how to tackle the subject with my own children. I would have been beaten up had I talked to my mom about being sexually active, that was my reality and I know it isn't unique. If there is a way to protect those teens who don't have the option of talking to their parents I say we should definately go for it. Just my thought though.
@la_vida_linda@xanga - well i'm glad you have a plan with your kids.and i'm sorry your mom was that way.i'll tell you when i went to my mom and asked her for birth control shesaid i thought you were already having sex and i was horrified!!!!she always told me she wouldnt stop me but wanted me to come to her so she could keep me as safe as possible.i guess i see how lucky i was to have a mom like her
Wait, I didn't hear about this.. why did they decide to all get pregnant??!? That's so ridiculous...
This attitude of "kids will do it anyway" totally ignores the fact that kids can and do have self control. We are not animals without a will and we should stop treating teens like they are.
Not every single teen has pre-marital sex. Giving teens condoms is no different than giving them clean needles because they "surely will use drugs." The worst part of all this is mothers that put their daughters on birth control so young men can take something precious from them. It's so unbelievably sad.
@Mrs_LeFevour@xanga - awww maybe i'm not in the minority!!!!thanks for speaking up on your views
I have to agree with your post. I know I had and have a very open relationship with my parents, but the topic of sex is never brought up at all, even to this day. I was sexually active very young (around 14/15) because I just wanted "it" over with. I was lucky enough that I have a disorder whose treatment is birth control, or who knows what may have happened to me back then. To this day I don't discuss "it" with my parents, and I wish I would have had easier access to information or consultation with a doctor about sexual things. Kids are going to have sex, whether or not they want them to, and with birth control at least accidents won't happen as often.