Wednesday, 23 July 2008

  • Breastmilk Does a Body Good!

    Nurse Jenna by Nurse Jenna

    Where are all the breastfeeding moms?

    Despite the numerous benefits of breastfeeding, recent data (2004) shows that only 31% of infants were exclusively breastfeeding at 3 months old and 11% at 6 months.

    Though there are many benefits to breastfeeding, recent studies show that one benefit is a reduced risk of both childhood and adult obesity. The longer an infant is breastfed, the lower the chances of the child (and then adult) of being overweight. For every month the baby is breastfed, up to 9 months of age, the risk for being overweight goes down by 4%. This means a 30% reduced risk for a child breastfed for 9 months versus a child never breastfed. Continuing to breastfeed may be one thing to help with epidemic obesity issues we now face (along with many other needed interventions).

    Did you breastfeed and if so, how long? Do most women find that continuing to breastfeed until at least 9-months is a realistic thing to be able to do with other life issues? Why do you think the numbers of exclusively breastfeeding babies is so low?

Comments (66)

  • OrdinaryInverted@xanga

    Great topic!


    I breastfed my boy until he wasn't interested anymore (for him that happened at about 10 months- he just started pushing me away & grabbing food off my plate!). I would have preferred to nurse him longer, but he's an independent lil guy!


    The midwife I work with says it's actually very rare for a woman to be physically unable to breastfeed. Apparently our crazy fast-paced lifestyle leaves our bodies so tired and dehydrated that a lot of women think they can't breastfeed... we had a lady recently who was getting 3 hours of sleep per 24 hours, and only drinking sugary flavored drinks, and she was mystified when her milk dried up.


    I don't have anything against women who choose to bottlefeed of course... but if you're willing to really work at breastfeeding, you can do it!


    @hannahtan528@xanga - I feel you. I passed up on the strong pain medication after my c section because I was bound and determined to breastfeed, and the painkiller was one of the ones that gets into your milk.

  • averyswife@xanga

    I breastfed my baby until she was 5 1/2 months old and then I started having problems with my milk supply.  So I bought a fancy pump and a bunch of herbs and vitamins and tried to get it back up.  Later a doctor told me that it was nearly impossible to re-create your milk supply when it's almost gone.  But I tried for almost two months and then gave up.  I was only producing 3 ounces a day.  Then for a month or so I breastfed every morning until she refused.  When I finally switched to formula it was like she was a completely different baby...happy, content, even more energetic.  I almost wish I had switched sooner, I felt like I had been starving her by forcing her to breastfeed.  Some women just can't keep up supply like others.  With my next baby I'll breastfeed again and be more careful about pumping extra to keep my supply up, but there's nothing wrong with using formula if breastfeeding is impossible.  They haven't been adding sugar to formulas in 30 years or so, so the nutritional value is pretty good.  Not as good as breastmilk because of the antibodies, but close.

  • iwantmycheez@xanga

    I'm just about 8 months in and I'm breastfeeding, though I pump when I'm at work and she takes a bottle when she's at the sitter's.  I've developed a good routine, though my supply is slipping a bit since she's getting solids introduced more.  I plan to breastfeed as long as I can, but probably not much past 1.5 years.  I juggle the idea of weaning her and letting her self-wean, though.

  • SwissMama

    @mommyofchloe@xanga - Every mom has a right to decide what she wants to feed her baby.  However, it is not fair to say that breastmilk and formula are equal.  Yes, babies raised on formula will turn out fine, it is still perfectly acceptable food.  BUT there are many many documented health benefits to babies who take in breast milk, and those cannot be denied (there are also many health benefits to the mom as well).   Formula is not "bad" but it is not equal to breast milk.  Research has shown this over and over again.  

    No one is saying that because a particular baby is fed formula they will be fat.  Instead we are looking at correlations and risk.  The data says that babies who feed on formula tend to have a higher risk of being overweight.  That could have nothing to do with the formula.  However it is reasonable to think that the type of food babies eat when they're so little could have an influence on how their bodies process foods later in life, and for some reason breastmilk vs formula may make a difference (there is also some new evidence that mom's diet while pregnant may influence how baby metabolizes food as an adult). 

  • StrawberryRose53@xanga

    In looking at my family, I'm not so sure this is true.  Then again, we're kind'of a mut bunch. 

  • miss_order@xanga

    Breastfeeding is rare because I think longer term breastfeeding corresponds to higher income, more highly educated women. Partially, more education means these women recognize the benefits and make the effort to either breastfeed or pump if they have to go back to work and higher income means they are probably married and have a spouse to help share the burden of childcare and they may have the luxury of being a stay-at-home mom.  Plus, with government assistance in purchasing formula to lower-income women, I think bottle-feeding ends up being easier.

  • LinzluvsGJ@xanga

    I breastfed my first daughter for 7 1/2 months.  I think the biggest reason that a woman stops nursing early or never starts is lack of information and support about it.  If it's not something they have been around, it's harder to envision yourself doing something!
    As for my second daughter, she is still nursing and she is 3 years, 2 months.  My son is also nursing (yes! I am tandem nursing AND nursed during my pregnancy!) and he is 1 year 3 months old.

  • Andrea_TheNerd@xanga

    The biggest thing we as a nation could do to help is make it mandatory for employers to provide a place for women to express breastmilk, and enough breaks in which to do it.  And last I heard, they have!  Even the military is on the ball, as they have now enabled a woman who exclusively breastfeeds her child to not be eligible for deployment. I think we can expect to see the number of breastfeeders rise.


    Also, my husband was exclusively bottlefed, and he's one of the skinniest guys I've ever met, he and his family.  Perhaps some people's genetics react worse with formula than others?

  • la_vida_linda@xanga

    @Kates533@xanga - I had a similar problem, although my supply didn't drop off until around month 6.  I wish it could have lasted longer, but at least they got some benefit.  *shrugs* I actually read a lot about the benefits of breast feeding before I had my first born and I had the support of a great lactation consultant and a great boss who let me bring my son to work with me.  Oh well the good things never last as long as we want them to...

  • anonymous

    my son is almost 14 months old & i breastfed exclusively for 12-1/2 months.  he still has 1 nursing a day, which i plan to wean him off of soon.

  • MelodicPuppy@xanga

    I wish I were still breastfeeding my son, who is almost 8 months old.  My milk supply dried up when he was almost 3 months old.  I blame it on going back on the pill at 6 weeks PP.  My gyno told me that ortho-lo dose was fine for bf moms, but now I think otherwise.  My husband's entire family is obese, my husband included- hopefully my son will get my family's side of the gene pool, where we struggle to put the weight on!

  • MelodicPuppy@xanga

    @evagarringer@xanga - i'm sorry but I have do disagree with you here.  low-income does not always mean low-education.  My husband and I are considered low-income and I have a flippin masters degree.  My husband's cousin has a high school education and she's a multi millionaire.  Go figure.  I hate stereotypes. 

  • mom2tomany

    My oldest I nursed till a year. My twins were premature and unable to nurse. I pumped for 3 months and stopped after I had a large supply and had issues pumping. With my 3rd child I nursed for six months, My last child I nursed for 9 months.

  • miss_order@xanga

    @MelodicPuppy@xanga - 

    I really wasn't asserting that they are low income because they are less-educated, but there are abundant statistics that support the correlation between education and income.

    Here is a link to the U.S. department of labor statistics:

    http://www.bls.gov/emp/emptab7.htm

    According to 2007 data, in general, persons with more educational attainment earn more than people with less. For example an individual with a B.S. degree earns 2.3 times as much per week as someone who didn't finish high school.

    What I was trying to get at is that lack of support for breastfeeding is one more disadvantage of being poor in America.

    Here is a link to a Wikipedia article with information from studies that show correlations of less breastfeeding with both income levels and education levels. It specifically references the fact that qualifying for WIC is associated with being less likely to breastfeed.

     http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breastfeeding#Sociological_factors_with_breastfeeding

    My basic point was that lack of education (in general and about breastfeeding specifically) and low income (associated with lack of education, less-friendly-to-pumping work environment/hours and government assistance in purchasing formula) contribute to women's choices to not breast feed.

  • mommyofchloe@xanga

    @SwissMama -

    I do agree that every mom has that right to decide what she wants to feed her child. It is her choice, and just because she chooses what is right for her, doesn't make her a bad person or a bad mother.
    Yes everyone around is pushing breastfeeding more so than formula. Even the hospital I work at encourages breastfeeding, we even have specialists who work with moms who have poor equipment such as flat, cracked nipples, etc., or have had reductions or implants or whatever their situation so that they can breastfeed. I am not saying breast feeding is bad, because it is quite the opposite. There are many benefits from breastfeeding such as how it is always ready at the right temperature for babies, and you never have to prepare a bottle.  It changes with the child as the they get older, and has all the antibodies in it as well. However, if you are one of those no binki and no bottle mom's, I think breastfeeding is more difficult. You have no one to take over with the feedings if you are tired or working, and even if you do let your child have a bottle, you still have to pump, and even so, working in a hospital, half the time we are lucky if we have time to eat for five minutes let alone be pumping 3 or 4 times a shift. Also, I do not like the idea of leaking milk. I have a friend who breastfeeds, and she leeks during the middle of the night. Plus I do not like the idea of the same boobs which turn my husband on be the same boobs to feed my child--seems kind of weird. Also, breastfeeding is supposedly easier but it seems like more work to me because of the whole public thing--you either have to go into the bathroom to feed your child or whip out a blanket to throw over yourself, and I know many people who cannot have any dairy, or certain other foods while they are breastfeeding. Plus I have done research with formula since my little girl had to have Alimentum formula which is a hypoallergenic formula, and they make formula very well now, way better than they used to. It still has all the vitamins and minerals and is very nutritious for babies.
    Also, my little girl is not fat just because I did not breastfeed her. She has always been very thin compared to her little chunky breastfed cousin. I know several people who breastfeed, and their babies are little chunks, and I have heard from doctors too that breastfed babies do tend to be a little on the chunky side. Plus once the child gets older, it's all about nutrition and exercise. Also it is about example. If you as a parent eat lousy and do not exercise, neither will your child. That is why need to teach our children about proper nutritious choices, and make sure they get exercise instead of watching TV or playing video games or surfing the internet all day.
    I do support people who wish to breastfeed, but it is not for everyone. As natural as it is supposed to be, it doesn't come natural. It could take a lot of work, and if people are willing to be that determined to breastfeed through the rough times good for them, but to some people, the frustrations and agony of breastfeeding are not worth it, and there are other options. It doesn't make you a bad mother if you do not feed from the breast. I will not be breastfeeding any of my other babies and you know what? That is just fine. My babies will turn out just as good as yours, and it is not right to assume that 'breast is best' if it is not for everyone.

  • mamahippo

    @mommyofchloe@xanga - I understand that your response is not about me or what I said, as the points you are bringing up have nothing to do with the comment I wrote to you.  I never called you a bad mother.  I do not think you are a bad mother.  I understand that there's many difficulties to breastfeeding if you do not have the luxury to stay home and must instead work and find the time to pump, etc.  I have myself been tempted to give up breastfeeding when it's gotten tough. 

    My comment was about the straight comparison of breastmilk vs formula.  Maybe in future studies we will find that the differences have gotten smaller and smaller, to the point of being negligible.  I'm just working on current research, that says that the 2 are not equivalent. 

    Again-- not calling you a bad mother at all.  I don't think your child will be harmed by having formula.  Obviously the majority of people these days, and for a few generations, have been formula-fed and have come out just fine.  There are many reasons to go either way.  Yes, I'd love for more women to breastfeed, but sometimes that's just not possible.  My main objection when I replied to you was your statement that formula and breastmilk are no different, that their values are the same, nutritionally, etc.  That is simply not true, if you look at the data.  I'm being a bit nitpicky here, but I tend to object when I see people saying things that aren't quite true.  It's not a value judgement on anyone or their abilities as a mother, just looking at the evidence and research made which has said over and over again that while formula is great, breastmilk is also better.

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.