Monday, 14 July 2008
-
Cleaning-Up a Relationship
by Nurse Jenna
Today I am taking a break from being “NurseJenna.” Today I am “Just-Jenna” because I have a day off work. Or so I thought. I spend my days at work taking care of other people (and teaching nursing students), so a day off just for me is cherished time, as I know many of you feel the same. So what did I do on my day of leisure? I cleaned the kitchen, the bathroom, took out the trash and recycling, and did laundry. Sad, isn’t it? I am not going to complain about my life in general because it is fantastic—I travel a lot, eat at amazing restaurants, spend time with friends, see Broadway productions, train for my marathon, etc. But in general, I also work… a lot.So… what is your point, Non-Nurse Jenna? My point is this: I spend a lot of my “free-time” cleaning. I know, I know—join the club.
This is a big issue in my household. How messy is tolerable? My boyfriend and I disagree. I would by no means say I am a neat-freak; I am tidy. He, on the other hand, is what I would call a slob, or as my friends say—a typical guy. What is so frustrating to me is that he is not bothered by the mess, but I am. So who do you suppose winds up cleaning? Me! Why? Because I’m the only one who cares. I’ve tried the nagging approach, the nice approach, and even resorted to begging. Nothing seems to work. I can say that this is easily the biggest point of contention in our relationship. I’m frustrated by the mess; he’s frustrated by my frustration.
Is who-does-what with regard to cleaning a big relationship challenge for other people? Does anyone else find that your level of concern for the mess is not equal?
Post a Comment
- Back to momaroo's Momaroo Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in momaroo's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)














Comments (106)
Hey guys are guys... take it for what you see, it most likely will not ever change... sorry to tell you.
LOL, I'm just happy if he takes out the trash.
I'm glad my husband is as much as a neat freak as I am. I still do 90% of the cleaning myself because I'm home all the time but it's that 10% he does that keeps me from getting resentful. I have a dry erase board on our fridge that I write his To Do list. He sees it every time he walks in to the kitchen so I don't feel like a nag having to repeat myself. That works pretty good for us.
Plus, he read in a magazine that husbands that do housework have sex more.
That's reason enough for him.
I fought the good fight of shared responsibility for household chores and I lost. I learned not too long ago that in my case, hubby tunes out the nagging and begging and pleading. He even tunes out the logic that keeping a clean home is one thing but having to walk behind him and clean up his messes like I would a child is wholly unattractive and not likely to put me "in the mood".
I finally decided that I was spending just as much energy trying to get him to help out (even if only cleaning up after himself) as I was doing all the housework myself. I resigned to my fate of wife AND maid. Now I am not saying all men are like this....but I decided that I had to take this information of my husband and make a decision. Is it worth a divorce or not? If not, I might as well let it go because I am not winning this one.
maybe to help lighten your load he can do something that is obvious when it needs done. like the laundry (if you trust you wont get all of your clothes back pink and 2 sizes too small!!) Although there are other chores I hate more, not having to worry about one really makes it a lot easier to do the other things. Like TornadoChaser said, that small amount of help keeps me from feeling like I do it ALL. because I can step back and remind myself that he is helping. Convincing him of that may be a different story though.
My only other advice is to get him to help you with something. I often ask my husband to dry the dishes for me as I wash them. It gives us some time to talk without the tv or the phone or anything. And it really makes it more tolerable! He hates doing dishes, but he doesnt mind spending the time with me. We both win!
We usually do the he does all the yard work and I keep the inside up (unless it gets bad from say... well his family being in town for the weekend... then he is expected to help... or if we need to clean up any before we have company)
But then he gets into these things where I tell him he needs to mow and he comes back with well when was the last time you cleaned the house? And it really starts to get annoying because I may not do a huge all over clean a lot but I usually clean up something small every couple of days. He also brings up me doing laundry... but it is hard for me to keep up with how much we have to do when he leaves all his clothes on the floor in the closet. I told him if he wants his clothes washed he needs to make sure they end up in the clothes hamper. I told him I wasn't doing laundry off the floor.
Anyway, my point is we try to split them up... him outside and me inside.
Our level for concern ranges. Sometime it's me who wants it more clean and others it is him. Those are the worst times because then one person ends up cleaning while complaining to the other person that they are not helping at all.
In the end it usually comes out pretty good though. It would be nice if we didn't have the little problems with how often each of us takes care of our portion of the chores for the house (or how often one person complains about the other not doing their part) but every once in a while it's nice to be a little lazy... You can't always rush around crazy trying to keep everything super neat.
If I need help David usually ends up doing dishes... and he can vacuum and take out the trash... I don't trust him with the laundry as much. I like doing my own laundry and David doesn't care.
I recommend reading Boundaries by Townsend and Cloud. It gives some practical advice on how to set boundaries (for yourself, not others) in any relationship. There are also Boundaries in Dating and Boundaries in Marriage by the same authors. Sometimes we just have to learn to let things go that aren't important... choose your battles, if you will. I too am a "tidy" person, and my boyfriend is not quite as tidy.
But he does well if I ask him kindly to pick up a little, and he appreciates the fact that I keep my place clean and live-able. If we were to get married, there would be a more in-depth conversation about this sort of thing, but since we are not living together, it doesn't matter so much right now.
Most people, only have time to clean on their day off.
@hannahtan528@xanga -I know most people only clean on their day off. But what about when both people are working full-time? (Or more than full-time) Who is supposed to be doing the cleaning? Only the person who cares about the mess? It is not a "day-off" issue so much as an "initiation" issue between two people who have full lives outside of household chores and no one is the stay-at-home participant.
@hannahtan528@xanga - I never have a day off...
Well, I'd suggest two ways of approaching the problem. The first is to manage expectations. You can't make him care as much as you do. As another "typical" guy, I am fine with being sanitary; it's a big leap to tidy.
On the other end, if it really becomes a problem, you should use the "first seek to understand, then to be understood" approach. That is, ask earnestly why he doesn't feel like cleaning. It's important that this be completely honestly attempted, and that you have stated his case to his satisfaction, i.e. he must be satisfied with your level of understanding (and don't go too fast, because he might want to gloss over this and just say "yeah" to make the process go faster; your own gut feeling on the matter shouldn't be ignored). Once that is accomplished, you can seek to be understood. Lay it out logically, because that is the only language guys understand. Something like how there's x-hours worth of cleaning and it should be split (maybe not evenly, but at least MORE evenly) or something like that. If he's not sanitary, bring up the health of the child(ren). Finally, if it really that important to you, he should want to clean just to make you happy. That's what loving someone is all about: sacrifice. But it's important that neither of you are resentful in the end. It can't end on a sour note, otherwise you've made no progress at all.
I recommend "For Men Only" by Shaunti Feldhahn and Jeff Feldhahn. My husband is not a slob, but there's no question that I care more about having a clean house than he does. He really connected with the idea (presented in this book) that women are like computers in that they can have lots of "windows" (i.e. projects, concerns, tasks) open at the same time. Now that he understands how cluttered my mind feels and how impossible it is for me to relax with all those "to do" items going through my head, he is much more willing to do quick little jobs here and there. I also try really hard to express my appreciation for anything he does, which makes a huge difference for him.
@HeavyThinker@xanga - I appreciate the male feedback. I do believe I "understand" (though as he reads my blog, I'm sure he will correct me if I'm wrong). I believe he doesn't feel like cleaning because he is tired at the end of the day and the way it is is 'good enough.' He does make great attempts to do things just to make me happy, and cannot be faulted on that part. Execution is another matter entirely. My take on this is that I, too, am tired, but the status of our place is NOT good enough. At this point I can't claim child endangerment (cat endangerment, perhaps...they are indeed cleaner than he is!) Although I eat,sleep and breathe babies, more hours of the week than not,....I do not actually live with any. I'm a "clean as I go" person (nurses tend to be) and it is very difficult watching someone funtion who allows ALL items in the fridge to expire before cleaning it. It is more like 2 different philosophies in life: Do you do laundry based on how much is dirty? Or based on how little clean remains? It is really a manifestation a bigger difference....but interestingly, one of our only clashing points. After thinking about this more. I'm going to take the pragmatic approach to its resolution--a cleaning person.
@Stephanie772@xanga - I like the analogy. I think the S.O will relate as well since he is a computer-guy. Thanks.
@TornadoChaser - Thanks...planning on implementing the dry erase board idea!
My boyfriend is a lot cleaner than your average guy, so he'll share household chores with me. It's a big plus that he's willing to do both cooking and dish washing if he sees I've had a long day.
My relationship with some of my roommates when it comes to cleaning, however, is more like your situation. I've given up on them and just clean up after them. For the record, they are girls as well.Â@mamafox - When do you get time for yourself?
um.. good luck.
those kind of habits prolly won't go away easily. i think .. my bf and i might be on similar lvl of clean...?
Wow, what a sucky thing to argue about... mess doesn't bother me much until it gets too much but I think if it bothered the person I love I'd probably make more of an effort.
@hannahtan528@xanga - I generally don't. I leave my older boys with my husband for an hour or two Saturday mornings and run my errands with my baby. And I take a 3 minute shower usually every day with all 3 kids in there asking questions. Those are my alone times. Haha! Being a SAHM, I clean, play with my children and spend time with my husband. I get a bit of interrupted time online or reading a book. I'm lucky if I can sit through a 30 minute show without having to pause it at least 3 times (gotta love DVRs). I love my life.
@mamafox - I'm glad you're enjoying your life, with your husband and kids.
@TornadoChaser - Haha, maybe if I tell my husband that he'll help out A LOT more. Lol. Maybe I should tell my roommate too, haha, he might like that as well. Haha.
I married a neat person. We are both about having a clean house, especially if company is coming over. My husband is sometimes more of a neat freak than I can be. He likes having things in order, of course he may be rubbing off on me, so I am starting to be that way too. Haha. Since I stay at home with the little one, and he works all day, I do most of the housework. The only problem we have is we have two roommates. One is my friend and the other is my husband's friend, but they are in a relationship. The guy doesn't work, but the girl does. In my sense, I think the guy should help out around the house since he doesn't do anything (and they do not have kids) at all around the house most of the day. He mostly sits on his computer or plays video games (typical guy). He is the one I should be nagging about cleaning. Haha. I feel like I clean up after him more than I do my own husband, lmao. That will definitely change though. Even if I do have to incorporate some kind of list of things for him to do.
But when we live just by ourselves, it is me doing the inside work and my husband does the outside work, which I am content with. I am not at all into mowing the lawn or working on our shed/barn at all. I hate sweating and the heat we have here. Plus I can get everything clean to my expectations quicker than others can. I am very picky about how clean something.
@shillyshara@xanga - and Boundaries with Children - just finished it and HIGHLY recommend. Heavy on biblical references (fyi nonChristians) but incredible and practical techniques
I learned the magic phrase - "You are responsible for your own fun!"